October Monthly Outlook: GBP/EUR and GBP/USD

Sterling to benefit from resurgent UK economy

From the eurozone, September’s two key events were ECB President Draghi’s announcement of his long-awaited bond-buying plan and the German Constitutional Court’s decision to approve the permanent bailout fund. Since then, there has been a real lack of any further concrete developments, which has understandably frustrated many market players and caused some risk aversion. As the next major event in the timeline of the eurozone debt crisis, speculation over the imminence of a Spanish bailout request is dominating market thinking at present. PM Rajoy does not actually appear to be much closer to making a formal request; he looks likely to wait until after Spanish regional elections to be held on October 21.

From the US, we have finally seen Ben Bernanke deliver what the market has been waiting for – more support for the US economy in the form of QE3. The move was priced in to a large extent but the dollar has been unable to stage any significant recovery in the immediate aftermath of the Fed’s announcement.

Conditions here in the UK continue to look a little brighter, though understandably many investors will still need further positive evidence to be truly convinced that the economy is on a path to a sustained recovery. However, with the Japanese and US central banks engaging in QE in September and the European Central Bank also taking monetary easing measures of its own (though rather more unconventional), the market is beginning to look more favourably upon the pound again.

GBP/EUR

Spanish delays will hurt the euro

Sterling has made a decent recovery against the euro in recent weeks, after what was quite a sharp decline as a result of the optimism that followed the announcement of the ECB’s bond-buying plan. There has been a positive response to some of the UK figures that have emerged in recent weeks; trade balance data revealed a dramatic rise in exports to destinations outside the EU, suggesting UK businesses are adapting to deteriorating eurozone demand. Meanwhile, UK unemployment figures continue to defy the overall weak picture of UK economic growth by making significant strides. From retail sales data to public sector borrowing figures, the UK economy has been beating market expectations time and again and this is filtering into some sterling strength. Another positive has emerged with the latest upward revision to the UK’s Q2 GDP figure to -0.4%, considerably better than the original estimate of -0.7%. Hopes are high for a very strong showing for the Q3 UK GDP figure released on October 26.

The minutes from the MPC’S September meeting revealed a unanimous vote against further QE (for now). The decision in favour of leaving the BoE 0.5% base rate unchanged was also unanimous. The fact that one MPC policymaker saw a good case for QE in September did not go unnoticed but as things stand, the Bank of England is understandably in wait-and-see mode. In light of the increased room for domestic optimism and the easing of financial conditions in the eurozone in recent weeks, it will not come as much of a surprise to learn that we are not expecting any fresh monetary easing measures from the Bank of England this month. November is likely to see the Bank assess its options much more carefully though.

Coinciding with strong economic figures has been an increased appetite for the pound as a relative safe-haven. Gilt yields have declined in recent sessions as investors attempt to take cover from renewed uncertainties from the eurozone and as usual this has boosted the pound by association. With the QE decisions from the US Federal Reserve and the Bank of Japan in September, sterling has climbed a little higher up many investors’ wish lists in recent weeks.

Putting improved UK conditions to one side, the major factor behind GBP/EUR’s climb in the past month has been a shift in sentiment against the euro, as is predominantly the case when this pair climbs. The market relief that followed the ECB’s commitment to buy unlimited quantities of distressed peripheral debt has well and truly worn off. Investors have refocused on the major issues facing Spain and Greece in particular.

PM Rajoy has thus far snubbed the opportunity to take advantage of the ECB’s offer to purchase Spanish debt, fully aware of the austerity demands that will accompany such intervention. Rajoy is under enormous pressure domestically, with the rich Catalonia region demanding independence and fierce protests taking place in Madrid over existing austerity measures. The market is likely to have to wait until after regional elections held on October 21 for Rajoy to bite the bullet, which leaves a good three weeks of frustration ahead. That said, if rating agency Moody’s cuts Spain’s credit rating to ‘junk’ status, then a spike in Spanish bond yields could force Rajoy’s hand a little sooner.

Greek saga remains volatile

The situation in Greece also remains typically uncertain. October is an important month too, with some chunky bond repayments maturing. Disagreements not only exist between Greece and the Troika (EU, ECB and IMF) but between the IMF and the EU. With the Greek debt profile blown even further off track by a deeper than expected recession, the IMF is now pushing for another Greek debt restructuring in order to get its debt sustainability back on track. Unsurprisingly, more ‘haircuts’ is not at the top of the EU’s list of priorities.

It looks as if there is some consensus over giving Greece an additional two years to meet its targets and the government appears to have been reached an agreement for €13.5bn in additional spending cuts that they hope will unlock the vital next tranche of aid. However, the agreement still needs Troika approval and would need to be approved by the Greek parliament, which amid violent public protests in Athens is no dead cert. Speculation has surrounded the need for a third Greek bailout but this option looks to be a non-starter as it would require parliamentary approval from individual member states. The bottom line is that Greece may well leave the eurozone but EU leaders are unlikely to let this happen while conditions in Spain remain so tense. The pressure for stronger signs of progress will be turned up once again at the next EU Summit on October 18-19.

Sterling has recouped its mid-September losses against the euro and is back trading above the €1.25 level. With market confidence so shaky at present, any concrete progress - most importantly from Spain in the form of a bailout request – will likely give the euro a significant lift. However, our baseline scenario is that this will not occur and that sentiment will continue to weaken towards the euro, helping sterling to build on its domestic economic resurgence and resume its uptrend against the euro.

GBP/USD

Dollar to strengthen despite QE3

The US Federal Reserve finally pulled the trigger on QE3 in September, which meant it was another very soft month for the US dollar. There have been some bright spots amongst US figures in the past month, with trade balance, retail sales and consumer confidence figures all showing some improvements. However, there has been plenty of evidence of continued economic weakness to support Ben Bernanke’s decision to turn the printing presses back on; last month’s key employment update gave little to cheer about. In addition, the final US GDP figure for Q2 was sharply and unexpectedly revised down to 1.3% from 1.7%.

The issues of weak US economic growth and a long period of quantitative easing are by no means at the top of most investors’ list of concerns. The US dollar has strengthened a little in the past fortnight, amid waning euphoria surrounding the QE3 announcement and the ECB’s pledge to purchase peripheral debt. Spain has not asked for a bailout, Greece has not secured its next tranche of aid and growth across the world is slowing. These are all dollar-friendly factors and the slowdowns being seen in China and the eurozone (including Germany) are of particular concern.

Whilst UK growth data has been remarkably positive in recent weeks, the ongoing fragility of the UK recovery has already been highlighted this week by a weaker than expected manufacturing figure. If sterling is to avoid another short-term sell-off against the US dollar, the UK services figure released on October 3 must be firm. However, sterling should get plenty of support in the form of the preliminary Q3 UK GDP figure released on October 26; we are looking for a robust quarterly showing of around +0.6%.

As things stand, sterling is trading almost two cents below September’s 13-month high of $1.63 and we think this high will remain a ceiling for this pair. Regardless of QE3, we see plenty of scope for increased demand for the safe-haven US dollar. We are still anticipating weakness in the EUR/USD pair, which should send GBP/USD back below $1.60 in October. 

Richard Driver

Currency Analyst

Caxton FX

Caxton FX Weekly Round-Up: Spanish bailout issue to weigh on euro

Market frustrations with Spain on the rise

Spanish PM Rajoy’s failure thus far to accept the inevitable and make a formal request for a bailout has weighed on the euro in recent sessions. The week ahead brings plenty of interest; we are due to see Spain’s draft budget for 2013, the results of the Spanish banking sector’s recent stress tests and an economic reform programme that is likely to be a prelude to a bailout package. Even if these developments are welcomed by the market, we still think that Rajoy will wait until after Spain’s regional elections on October 21, which leaves several more weeks of uncertainty and frustration. This should delay any further euro rallies.

On the Greek front, we have seen some alarming headlines that the budget deficit is nearly twice as large as initially estimated. Talks between Greece and the Troika are now on a one week hiatus, so the market is left with alarming rumours of the need for a third Greek bailout and another Greek debt restructuring. The option of granting Greece more time to meet its bailout targets is gaining support but at this stage we are very much in speculation territory.

Concerns over eurozone growth have returned to the fore this week, after another awful German business climate survey. The risks of a German recession are rising, a development which the periphery can ill-afford.

Sterling firm ahead of final GDP number

The pound is performing well across the board at present. Eurozone concerns have returned after an August lull, while the central banks of Japan and the US have both eased monetary policy further, leaving sterling to reap the rewards. In addition, UK data has improved in recent weeks and the BoE seems to be content for the time being to delay any further QE of its own.

Sterling should be able to hang on to its recent gains against the euro and perhaps even build upon them, provided that Thursday’s final UK GDP number for Q2 does not suffer a downward revision to the already worrying   -0.5% reading. This release, which is likely to remain unrevised, is the only major event on the domestic calendar this week. By and large, the market’s gaze will be firmly fixed upon Spain.

US dollar soft after QE3 decision but continues to look poised for a bounce

Sterling remains at heady heights close to a 13-month high against the US dollar, thanks in no small part to the Fed’s decision to do a third round of QE earlier this month. However, the dollar’s behaviour since the decision suggests the move was more than a little bit priced in. Certainly the pound has climbed against the greenback but it has really stalled at the $1.63 level, so much so that we expect the rate to fall back in the coming weeks (provided that Rajoy doesn’t surprise us with an early bailout request)

End of week forecast

GBP / EUR	1.2625
GBP / USD	1.6150
EUR / USD	1.2800
GBP / AUD	1.5600

Risk appetite is pretty weak at present and the flow of news out of the eurozone is predominantly very negative. There remain disagreements over the EU banking union, over the legality of the ECB’s bond-buying programme, over the cession of Catalonia from Spain and much more besides. With this in mind, the GBP/USD rate’s ceiling of $1.63 looks likely to hold firm in the coming sessions. Meanwhile against the euro, sterling looks better placed to climb further. A move back up above €1.26 is a likely one this week.

Richard Driver

Currency Analyst

Caxton FX

Spanish bailout will come but not for another month

The newswires have today been full of speculation over the imminence of a Spanish bailout. The FT has reported this week that negotiations between Spain and the EU are going places. The two parties are working on an economic reform programme which is rumoured to be unveiled next week. Note though, this is only a prelude to a bailout request.  

What is Spanish PM Rajoy waiting for? Well, regional elections in the Basque country and Galicia are being held on October 21 and Rajoy is likely to wait until after that, as a bailout request before this date would more likely than not damage his Conservative party’s chances. This end of October period coincides with some major Spanish debt repayments and is probably as long as the market is willing to wait for some concrete progress.

There is something to be said for getting in early with a bailout request whilst bond yields are away from their record highs, so that Rajoy is in a better position to negotiate favourable bailout conditions. If Rajoy waits until the situation returns to panic mode, Spain’s creditors could have him over barrel.

Next Friday’s release of the Spanish banking sector’s stress tests could well spook the markets and send bond yields soaring up to 7.0% again but on balance we expect Rajoy to wait until late October, just in time for the ECB’s meeting in the first week of November. This leaves time for bailout conditionality to be ironed out between the interested parties.

We believe Rajoy will use the next month to try everything he can to achieve the best result for his country. He is under huge domestic political pressure by an increasingly angry and volatile population and cannot afford to be seen to sacrifice more than is absolutely necessary in return for a bailout. Everything should be in place by the end of October and until then, the euro is likely to come under increasing selling pressure.

Richard Driver

Currency Analyst

Caxton FX

Roadmap to the Spanish debt crisis

This week is of huge significance to Spain and it might be interesting to give a brief roadmap of how Spain got into its current predicament. Up until 2008, the Spanish economy had been doing well. For instance, real estate prices rose 200% from 1996 to 2007 and the Spanish banking system (with small local banks known as ‘cajas’) had been viewed as one of the best equipped to deal with a financial crisis. Prior to 2008, some regions of Spain were very close to having full employment.

So what went wrong? In the third quarter of 2008, Spain’s economy officially entered recession, after 15 consecutive years of growth. Not a big surprise really, seeing as most countries around the world also went into recession during this period. Rating agency Standard and Poor’s then downgraded Spain’s prized AAA to AA+ in 2009. So, they adopt an economic stimulus plan worth about 5% of their GDP, which leads to the exiting recession in the first quarter of 2010. Things look optimistic.

Then investors start to take a closer look at the Spanish economy and realize that the public deficit is huge: 11.2% of their GDP. After admitting Spain was in trouble, Prime Minister Zapatero introduced austerity measures to address the problem. He raised the retirement age from 65 to 67, reformed pensions and passed a constitutional amendment forcing governments to maintain a balanced budget. Zapatero was then voted out in late 2011, and Mario Rajoy’s conservative party filled the void with an absolute majority.

However, the Spanish economy was already on a downward slide, having produced no growth in Q3 and suffering a 0.3% contraction in Q4 2011. By March, unemployment had doubled the Eurozone average by climbing to 24.4% (it now soars above 25%). In April, thousands protested across the country against the government cuts, adding political instability into the mix.

In the summer of last year the Spanish banking sector began to crumble. Bankia requested a €19 billion state rescue in May, which pushed Spain itself into requesting €100 billion bailout for the struggling banks. In July, one of Spain’s richest regions, Catalonia, requested aid from the central government and several more followed suit as the gravity of the crisis surfaced. With borrowing costs setting fresh record-highs, it has come to a tipping point which appears to have prompted action from the ECB.  

It goes without saying that the European Central Bank’s meeting in Frankfurt tomorrow could be crucial in the context of the Spanish and wider eurozone debt crisis. ECB President Mario Draghi has assured the market that the bank would buy enough bonds on the open market to put a stop to the “financial fragmentation” that currently exists throughout Europe. Draghi has hinted only this week that the ECB is free to buy government bond maturing in three years or less, without breaking the EU treaties and overstepping its mandate by stepping in to money-printing terrritory. This has already had a dampening effect on Spain’s soaring borrowing costs.

Whether the ECB unveils its plan to intervene in the bond markets on Thursday or not, it will do so fairly soon, that much has become pretty clear. But if a country wants to get their hands on this attractive offer from the ECB, they will first have to agree to a set of conditions. Just how strict these conditions are will determine how quickly Spanish PM Mariano Rajoy agrees to request help from the ECB.  He asserted last week, "When I know exactly what is on offer I will take a decision.” Rajoy will not be able to get the ECB’s help for free but certainly Merkel needs to be careful in not overstepping the mark when making austerity demands of Spain’s already crippled economy. There is bound to be plenty of brinkmanship involved if Spain is to request help.

Whilst the ECB meets tomorrow, Rajoy and Merkel will be also be meeting, where it is anticipated that the two leaders will be negotiating an estimated €300bn Spanish sovereign bailout. September was always ear-marked as an all-action month and it looks as if we could indeed be on the brink of some major developments. Whether or not the market will be convinced remains to be seen.

Harry Drake
Caxton FX