Spain formally requested assistance from its Eurozone partners on Monday, in light of the continued deterioration of its domestic banks. Luis de Guindos, the Spanish Economy Minister, sent the letter to Jean-Claude Juncker, who heads the group of Eurozone finance ministers, in the hope of obtaining a bailout loan thought to be in the region of €100bn. However, a lack of detail over the size of the bailout is a source of considerable market uncertainty. The news was fully expected following weeks of speculation over the condition of Spanish banks, and following the first call for help on 9th June.
What is also a source of nerves is where the bailout funds will come from. The recent bank restructuring in Ireland could be used as a precedent, in which case the loans would be channeled from the existing bailout fund, the European Financial Stability Mechanism, into Spain’s Fund for Orderly Bank Restructuring (Frob), which in turn will direct the money to those banks that need it. In this model, the loans would rank equally with private bondholders. If the loans come from the European Stability Mechanism, the new bailout fund, they will rank as senior debt and with the Greek haircuts fresh in the memory, the result would be investors hitting Spain will higher borrowing costs. The former option looks to be the likely choice. Another key concern is that as the bailout loans are likely to be channeled through Spain’s government, this means adding billions to Spain’s sovereign debt and increasing the country’s debt-to-GDP ratio considerably (from 70% to 80%). Again, this will have implications in Spain’s credit rating and borrowing costs.
These two factors are already an issue; Moody’s has downgraded Spanish debt to Baa3 (one higher than ‘speculative’), as well as issuing 28 fresh downgrades to Spain’s banks yesterday. This has resulted in a rise in the yield on Spanish 10-year debt to 7%, the government appears to be edging towards a sovereign bailout. Whilst in the short-term a bailout of the eurozone’s fourth largest economy would be a huge source of huge panic, a Spanish bailout may be the kick that EU leaders need to finally break ground on a long-term path to solving the debt crisis. Only time will tell.
So how has the euro responded? The Greek election result provided only a temporary respite and with the ongoing issue of the Greek bailout renegotiation ahead Spain edging closer to disaster, market tensions are rising. The euro has suffered a downwards correction in the past few sessions, dipping from $1.27 to $1.25, and allowing GBP/EUR to climb from €1.24 to €1.25. We maintain a negative outlook for the euro.
The EU Summit at the end of this week provides ample opportunity to calm market nerves, though the track record of these crisis meetings producing major progress is not a good one. Merkel has been typically stubborn on issues such as mutualised debt (Eurobonds) and with the Greek PM ill, no progress is likely to be made on the Greek bailout issue. Decisions with regard to Spain will be crucial if stocks are to avoid a further sell-off and if building pressures in the bond markets are to ease. The euro could be poised for a move lower.
Adam Highfield
Caxton FX
