German confidence tumbles again, pointing to possible German recession

A monthly German survey, which covers around seven thousand firms, has been released this morning to reveal that German business confidence has declined for the fifth consecutive month. A flat reading was expected but German business confidence has now dipped to its weakest level seen since March 2010. The news provides further evidence of the dampening effects of the eurozone debt crisis on the region’s powerhouse economy and has accordingly weighed on the single currency today.

Firms in manufacturing, construction, trade and industry were mostly responsible for the poor climate reading, though retail and wholesale trade did improve slightly. The regional downturn is having a particularly noticeable impact on Germany’s exports to other eurozone nations. The economic weakness being seen in major nations like Spain, Italy and even France cannot be viewed in isolation; recessions are particularly contagious in a currency union like the eurozone and this morning’s data indicates that Germany is succumbing.

Interestingly though, an economist from the producers of the data - the Institute for Economic Research - has stated that German consumption remains robust despite a weaker labour market and therefore does not see a need for an interest rate cut from the European Central Bank. An interest rate cut would however weaken the euro, which could boost exports outside the eurozone, though this would require Germany’s preoccupation with high inflation to be set aside. The IFO economist did also note that the survey was taken prior to the positive decision from the German Constitutional Court earlier this month, the uncertainty surrounding which may be at least partly responsible for the unexpected decline.

The economic downturn is not just bad news for Germany but for the eurozone’s peripheral nations as well. If Germany enters recession, then it is going to be increasingly difficult for Merkel to justify and deliver the support she is pledging for struggling nations like Spain and Italy. With plenty more austerity measures still to come across the eurozone, the prospects for the economy as a whole and Germany by association, are rather gloomy. After Q2’s 0.3% GDP growth, Germany may avoid economic contraction in Q3 but the same is unlikely to be true in Q4, such is the downtrend that is in place. This is not to say that Germany is certain to enter a recession but the risks are very significant and it is looking increasingly likely, which is bad news for all concerned.

We may have seen some progress on the debt crisis in the last month or so but economically, the region is in very poor shape indeed, which is in part why we maintain a negative outlook for the euro.

Richard Driver

Currency Analyst

Caxton FX

Spanish bailout will come but not for another month

The newswires have today been full of speculation over the imminence of a Spanish bailout. The FT has reported this week that negotiations between Spain and the EU are going places. The two parties are working on an economic reform programme which is rumoured to be unveiled next week. Note though, this is only a prelude to a bailout request.  

What is Spanish PM Rajoy waiting for? Well, regional elections in the Basque country and Galicia are being held on October 21 and Rajoy is likely to wait until after that, as a bailout request before this date would more likely than not damage his Conservative party’s chances. This end of October period coincides with some major Spanish debt repayments and is probably as long as the market is willing to wait for some concrete progress.

There is something to be said for getting in early with a bailout request whilst bond yields are away from their record highs, so that Rajoy is in a better position to negotiate favourable bailout conditions. If Rajoy waits until the situation returns to panic mode, Spain’s creditors could have him over barrel.

Next Friday’s release of the Spanish banking sector’s stress tests could well spook the markets and send bond yields soaring up to 7.0% again but on balance we expect Rajoy to wait until late October, just in time for the ECB’s meeting in the first week of November. This leaves time for bailout conditionality to be ironed out between the interested parties.

We believe Rajoy will use the next month to try everything he can to achieve the best result for his country. He is under huge domestic political pressure by an increasingly angry and volatile population and cannot afford to be seen to sacrifice more than is absolutely necessary in return for a bailout. Everything should be in place by the end of October and until then, the euro is likely to come under increasing selling pressure.

Richard Driver

Currency Analyst

Caxton FX

Bank of Japan follows suit and eases monetary policy but the yen remains strong

 Last night’s monetary policy decision from the Bank of Japan saw further support provided to the Japanese economy. The BoJ added to its existing asset purchase programme by Y10trn, taking the total purchases to Y80trn. This Y10trn increase has come earlier than many expected and was certainly more than most market players expected. BoJ also extended the deadline for the end of the programme by six months to the end of 2013.

Nerves over the global economy are a major factor behind the BoJ’s decision. The US recovery remains shaky, the risks of a Chinese hard landing are rising, while there is little doubt that the eurozone has not seen the worst of the current economic contraction.

Global conditions have contributed to what the BoJ has described as a “pause” in the domestic Japanese economy. BoJ Governor Shirokawa has said the Japanese recovery has been set back by six months thanks to a prolonged global economic slowdown. Exacerbating the domestic growth outlook is the fact that a territorial dispute between China and Japan threatens to disrupt trade relations, something Japan can ill-afford.

Also in the BoJ’s mind will be the desire to curb the appreciation of the yen, which is hurting the Japanese economy. Particularly in light of the US Federal Reserve at last announcing QE3 this month, another move from the BoJ was always likely. However, the yen hasn’t weakened off today as much as the Japanese official would have liked. It has retraced almost all of last night’s losses, which demonstrates that there is no guarantee that QE will weaken a currency. 

Richard Driver

Currency Analyst

Caxton FX

RBA signals interest rate cuts in October

The Reserve Bank of Australia released the minutes from its September meeting last night and the Australian dollar has since weakened. This is because the minutes were probably the most dovish we have seen from the RBA in six months, suggesting a cut to its 3.50% interest rate could be just around the corner. To say the RBA has signaled a move may be an overstatement but the we are hearing the hints loud and clear.

The minutes included the assertion that "the current assessment of the inflation outlook continued to provide scope to adjust policy in response to any significant deterioration in the outlook for growth." This is a telling statement.

Australian data has not overall been particularly positive of late but it is hardly reason for the RBA to panic. Indeed, the RBA appears to be confident that domestic growth is on the right path. Investment looks to be positive for the rest of the year, consumer confidence is up and the unemployment picture is relatively stable, as shown by the recent fall to 5.1%.

Rather, evidence of renewed weakness in the Chinese economy is a major driver. Linked to this is the second issue on the RBA’s mind, which is declining commodity prices, in particular iron ore and coal prices. It’s not just China that the RBA is concerned with either; data from the eurozone and the US is also pointing to a further global slowdown.

So the bank has changed from a neutral tone to an easing bias. The comments reflect those within the RBA’s March meeting, which was followed by a 0.50% interest rate cut in April. We don’t expect a 0.50% cut in October, but we do expect a 0.25% cut, and then another in November or December. The Fed and the ECB’s recent monetary policy decisions will surely aid global growth eventually but this will take time to feed through and results won’t come soon enough for the RBA.

Richard Driver

Currency Analyst

Caxton FX

Rejection of further austerity leaves Spanish bailout in limbo

Spanish PM Rajoy has made no secret of his aversion to EU-dictated austerity measures in return for a bailout. The financial markets and Germany in particular are demanding further Spanish cuts but Rajoy’s response last week was; “"I will look at the conditions but I would not like, and I could not accept, being told which were the concrete policies where we had to cut." His country's economy is already in shreds after a July austerity-drive. 

Thousands of angry Spaniards marched in protest in Madrid over the weekend, demanding a referendum to decide on the government’s measures. Tensions and unrest in the country are at such levels now that Spanish finance minister Luis de Guindos has responded by ruling out further spending cuts. He said “Spain's existing measures are significant and ambitious enough” to meet the EU’s target of a budget deficit that 3.0% of GDP by 2014. It is common knowledge that Mr de Guindos is quite incorrect in saying this, and he well knows it, but it is in his country’s interest to keep up the charade.  

But where does this leave Spain with respect to the European Central Bank? Whilst the market went wild for the ECB bond-buying plan just over a week ago, the fact remains that Spain must officially request a bailout if it is to benefit from the plan. It will not do so if Germany’s demands are too onerous.

The announcement of the ECB’s bond-buying plan has bought Spain a little bit of time by bringing borrowing costs down, coming way down from the 7.0% level (10-year debt). Nonetheless, yields are back on the rise and the clock is very much ticking. Deposits are being withdrawn from Spanish banks at an alarming rate amid the current crisis of confidence, which will necessarily constrict the banks’ ability to support much-needed economic growth with lending.  

In an indication that Spain is edging towards a bailout request, it has pledged to unveil a reform programme on September 28, which will include clear deadlines and intended structural changes. We are still in the dark over bailout terms though and this is likely to be a huge source of uncertainty in the coming weeks. 

And how has the euro started the week? Well its rally has stalled, as it consolidates on last week's hefty gains. However, the market euphoria with respect to the ECB pledge to flash the cash and the Fed's decision to pull the trigger on QE3 may well give the euro further support in the coming sessions. 

Richard Driver

Currency Analyst

Caxton FX

Swedish Krona set for further losses

The Swedish krona continues to trade at impressive levels across the exchange rates. The krona has been boosted by an ongoing recovery in market confidence, driven in particular by some key breakthroughs in the eurozone. This confidence has fed into sustained appetite for higher-yielding currencies like the SEK.

The key development from Europe this summer has been the ECB’s pledge to provide unlimited bond-purchases for peripheral eurozone countries like Spain and Italy, whose soaring borrowing costs have been a major feature this year. The ECB’s pledge has already had a very positive impact on eurozone bond yields and has eased some of the more immediate concerns that the debt crisis may spiral out of control before EU leaders can react. The improved global sentiment has been given another boost by the German Constitutional Court’s approval of the European Stability Mechanism, which is to be the eurozone’s permanent bailout fund. While the issue of firepower is by no means solved, the eurozone’s ability to respond to Spain and Italy’s refinancing needs has certainly improved.

Sentiment towards the Swedish economy remains broadly positive, which isn’t surprising given the outstanding Q2 GDP figure released in late July, which smashed forecasts. 1.4% quarterly growth is probably more than most G10 economies can hope to achieve throughout 2012 as a whole. Domestic consumption remains in good shape and the Swedish export sector’s continues to stand up pretty well in the face of deteriorating growth and demand in the eurozone. However, there has been some recent economic weakness that may persuade many investors to give up on hopes for any further SEK rallies.

GBP/SEK Outlook

The situation in the UK has been fairly grim this summer, with data confirming that on top of Q1’s 0.3% contraction, the UK economy contracted by another 0.5% in the second quarter, with the extra Bank Holiday as a result of the Queen’s Diamond Jubilee weighing particularly heavily.

However, the UK economy is showing some solid signs of turning a corner in Q3. Industrial and manufacturing production data has shown some excellent growth, the UK services sector bounced back in July, while the latest trade balance and labour statistics have also been very positive. Thanks in no small part to the London Olympics, there is now a decent chance of a positive Q3 GDP figure, which should result in some support for the pound.

Also supportive of the pound is the near-term outlook for Bank of England monetary policy. The BoE appears content to sit it out and wait for the effects of both its Funding for Lending programme and its last QE top-up, before easing monetary policy any further. Conditions in the eurozone have eased up, while domestic activity has improved in the past couple of months, which should ensure there is no more QE until November at the very earliest.

There is no doubt that the Swedish spent Q2 in rude health but there have been some mildly concerning figures released of late. August saw a surprise rise in unemployment to 7.2% from 7.0% and a very weak manufacturing growth figure, while the latest industrial orders data suggests there could be some further weakness down the line. However, it was weak Swedish inflation, not tame growth figures, which prompted the Riskbank to cut its base rate by 0.25% to 1.25% in September.  While Swedish krona’s interest rate differential has now been eroded, the market’s response was quite muted.

This pair posted fresh multi-month lows in the past fortnight, amid a series of positive eurozone developments. However, support levels have kicked in at 10.5, which has coincided with stronger UK figures and a slight loss in momentum in Sweden. These factors should combine to send GBP/SEK pair higher off these current lows in the coming month. 10.7-10.8 is a decent target area.

Richard Driver

Currency Analyst

Caxton FX

Swiss National Bank holds firm on EUR/CHF floor

Away from the wild speculation surrounding the US Federal Reserve’s meeting this evening and away from the strides being made in the eurozone, the Swiss National Bank gave its quarterly monetary policy assessment this morning. As expected, the SNB kept interest rates on hold in the 0-0.25% band. Slightly more interesting than this, however, was the SNB’s decision to reiterate its commitment to defending the EUR/CHF floor (or ceiling if you prefer to look at it that way) of 1.20.

Since the escalation of the eurozone debt crisis, the safe-haven franc attracted huge investment and the excessive appreciation that this caused was damaging to the Switzerland’s economy. In August 2011, the Swiss National Bank responded by intervening in the currency markets to weaken the franc (put simply, buying lots of euros and selling lots of francs). In September 2011, the SNB set a floor for the EUR/CHF exchange rate, pledging to use all the resources at its disposal not to allow the franc to strengthen past this point (below a rate of 1.20).

Since September 2011 then, any dip below the 1.20 threshold has been fleeting and marginal, but the market has certainly tested the SNB’s resolve. Central banks currency intervention is historically very unsuccessful and expensive, just ask the Bank of Japan. Up until now though, the SNB is doing a remarkably good job but only time will tell. 

Swiss National Bank's statement this morning has told us that they expect the Swiss economy to grow by 1.0% this year, down from the 1.5% growth they expected three months ago (though this is still a decent pace of growth). In addition, the SNB also sees consumer prices falling by 0.6%, more than initially expected, with inflation expectations for 2013 and 2104 also downgraded. 

In light of downgraded growth and inflation expectations, the SNB was quite clear on its on-going commitment to maintain the EUR/CHF floor this morning, stating that “If necessary, it stands ready to take any further measures at any time.” It’s not surprising either, the swiss franc remains overvalued. With near-term risks to Swiss growth high given the poor growth outlook for the eurozone economy, the SNB is likely to maintain its defensive stance in the medium term. However, talk of shifting the floor even higher up to 1.25 looks unlikely to be realised, as the SNB will probably view this as too risky. 

Richard Driver

Currency Analyst

Caxton FX

The German Constitutional Court gives the euro another boost

After weeks and week of delay, Germany’s top Constitutional Court has ratified the European Stability Mechanism - the eurozone’s permanent bailout fund. The court ruled that the ESM does not conflict with the German constitution and Italian PM Mario Monti has today stated that this “has removed the last obstacle for the implantation of the ESM treaty and the fiscal compact treaty.”

There are a few ‘buts’ though, which probably means Monti is jumping the gun a little. Whilst the ESM treaty does oblige the German government to contribute €80bn up front and further contributions upon bailout requests down the line, the German court has limited Germany’s contribution to €190bn. This is a significant condition and may prove to be insufficient given the refinancing needs of Spain and Italy. Italy could potentially decide to it is unable to contribute to the ESM due to the state of its own finances - Germany is unlikely to step willingly into the void. In addition, the court rejected granting the ECB a banking license and in doing so highlighted a continuing lack of firepower.

However, Germany's liability could be increased with the approval of the Bundestag, though such approval seems unlikely given the momentum of bailout-fatigue sentiment among the electorate. Another condition was included that both German House of parliament must be kept informed of ESM decisions, which does have the potential to delay future decisions.  

The ESM’s governing board will meet in early October for the first time but Eurogroup head Juncker has said it will not be activated before January 1, 2013. The euro has rallied again today, focusing on the disaster that was avoided rather than the considerable issues that remain. The euro may be to climb a little further on the back of a QE3 announcement tomorrow evening but it is fair to say this rally is looking increasingly overextended. 

Richard Driver

Currency Analyst 

Caxton FX

UK trade deficit narrows to an 18-month low

Trade balance data for July has revealed this morning that the UK trade deficit has narrowed to a February 2011 low of 7.1B. This was lower than the 8.9B deficit that was anticipated and significantly lower than the 10.1B deficit shown in August. 

At 9.0%, overall export sales growth was at its highest level since 1998. Sales of goods outside the eurozone grew by 11%, while somewhat surprisingly, sale of goods to the eurozone even grew by almost 8.0%. More positive news for the economy, then, and it certainly takes some of the considerable pressure off the UK government.

It is encouraging to see UK businesses respond to the challenges facing them, in the form of low confidence and deteriorating economic conditions in the eurozone, by diversifying their global trade relations. Increased take-up from the US, Asia (especially India) and South Africa all contributed to this morning’s improved figure. Oil exports to the eurozone was also a key factor in helping the July trade balance bounce back from June’s disappointing showing, which was the worst since modern records began 15 years ago.

Once again this points to a rebound for UK GDP in the third quarter. Awful trade balance figures were a real drag on growth last quarter, which unless we see another dramatic reversal in August and September, will not be the case in Q3. It goes without saying that this figure does not change a very uncertain outlook for UK exporters. The flow of bad news out of the eurozone has been stemmed somewhat over the summer but for as long as the region’s economy contracts, a cloud will remain over many UK businesses. Nonetheless, this is again good news for the UK and no doubt Chancellor George Osborne will sleep a little easier tonight.

Richard Driver

Currency Analyst

Caxton FX

Caxton FX Weekly Outlook: Further upside potential for euro

ECB plan triggers euro rally

Mario Draghi alluded to doing “whatever it takes” to save the euro a month or so ago and at last week’s ECB press conference, he outlined just what he meant by that. ‘Super Mario’ as he has been called, revealed a plan that involves the ECB purchasing unlimited amounts of peripheral eurozone nations’ bonds. This has already brought down Spain’s bond yields but as Moody’s has warned today, this does not solve the crisis, it merely buys EU politicians (and not the ECB) the time to address the region’s fiscal and structural shortcomings.

The ball is now effectively in Spain’s court to negotiate acceptable conditions of a bailout that would include ECB intervention in the bond markets. So we are back to the familiar balancing act of Germany extracting sufficient austerity measures without going ‘over the top.’ This could potentially weeks but there is plenty to watch out for in the interim.

Wednesday should bring the German Constitutional Court’s ruling on the legality of the European Stability Mechanism and the eurozone’s fiscal compact. The court is strongly expected to approve both initiatives but a complaint made today by a German MP regarding last week’s ECB bond-buying plan has raised the prospect of another possible delay to the decision, which has ramped up market nerves again.

Wednesday also brings the Netherlands' general election but the euro looks likely to be spared another political saga at this stage, with the latest polls indicating a close race between two pro-Europe parties.

QE3 could finally arrive this week

Going into last Friday’s non-farm payroll figure the chances of the Fed delaying QE3 for the time being were fairly well balanced but it now seems highly likely that Ben Bernanke will at last pull the trigger on Thursday. Ironically, data did reveal that the US unemployment rate did fall to a rate not bettered since January 2009. Unfortunately as the employment change figure revealed, this was not because more jobs has been taken up and will be of little comfort to the Fed. QE3 is priced into a decent extent after Friday’s dollar sell-off but there is every chance we could see another wave of risk appetite give the greenback another knock this week.

Hints of a Q3 rebound for the UK economy

 August’s PMI growth figures from the manufacturing and services sectors were much better than expected last week. In addition, data also revealed that UK manufacturing and industrial production grew at their fastest rates in 10 and 25 years respectively, bouncing back from June’s slump. This summer’s London Olympics also look likely to have made quite a sizeable contribution to the domestic growth, which has caused many to revise up their GDP forecasts for Q3. All this means that QE concerns should not apply any weight to the pound for the next few weeks at least.

Although the euro’s upward climb has stalled today, the prospect of QE3 from the Fed and a positive ruling from the German Constitutional Court could well give the single currency some further strength. This is likely to keep the GBP/EUR pinned close to or even temporarily below the €1.25 level. Against the USD, matters are rather different as the pound currently sits only marginally off a near-fourth month high. Renewed upside potential for the EUR/USD pair could well help the GBP/USD hang on to these gains in the short-term but we continue to expect a reversal in the coming weeks.  

End of week forecast

GBP / EUR	1.2450
GBP / USD	1.6050
EUR / USD	1.2890
GBP / AUD	1.5300

Richard Driver

Currency Analyst

Caxton FX