Weak growth outlook hurting the euro today

How quickly the market has moved on from President Obama’s re-election! Focus is back squarely on the eurozone and sterling has enjoyed another nudge higher against the euro as the latter has been sold-off quite aggressively.

What’s behind this fresh euro-weakness? German industrial production data for the month of September has come in at an alarming -1.8% this morning, which represents a five-month low. To make things worse, eurozone retail sales data also revealed an unexpected contraction this morning.

The EU Commission has also added extra weight to the single currency, by releasing pessimistic growth forecasts for the eurozone.  It sees eurozone GDP shrinking by 0.4% this year, before growing by just 0.1% next year. Greece is to contract by a staggering 6.0% this year and by another 4.2% next year. EU Commissioner Rehn sounded distinctly downbeat in his press conference today, citing tightening credit conditions and weakening demand.

GBP/EUR climbed to a five-week high of €1.2530, whilst EUR/USD fell to nearly a two-month low of $1.2735. We have been citing downside risks to the euro on the basis of the eurozone’s dire economic outlook for some time now. The increasing evidence of Germany’s decline is making the market stand up and take notice. Watch out for tonight’s Greek austerity vote, as the euro could get some relief if, as it should do (though only just), the Greek parliament approves the latest austerity proposals. 

Richard Driver,

Currency Analyst

Caxton FX

October Monthly Outlook: GBP/EUR and GBP/USD

Sterling to benefit from resurgent UK economy

From the eurozone, September’s two key events were ECB President Draghi’s announcement of his long-awaited bond-buying plan and the German Constitutional Court’s decision to approve the permanent bailout fund. Since then, there has been a real lack of any further concrete developments, which has understandably frustrated many market players and caused some risk aversion. As the next major event in the timeline of the eurozone debt crisis, speculation over the imminence of a Spanish bailout request is dominating market thinking at present. PM Rajoy does not actually appear to be much closer to making a formal request; he looks likely to wait until after Spanish regional elections to be held on October 21.

From the US, we have finally seen Ben Bernanke deliver what the market has been waiting for – more support for the US economy in the form of QE3. The move was priced in to a large extent but the dollar has been unable to stage any significant recovery in the immediate aftermath of the Fed’s announcement.

Conditions here in the UK continue to look a little brighter, though understandably many investors will still need further positive evidence to be truly convinced that the economy is on a path to a sustained recovery. However, with the Japanese and US central banks engaging in QE in September and the European Central Bank also taking monetary easing measures of its own (though rather more unconventional), the market is beginning to look more favourably upon the pound again.

GBP/EUR

Spanish delays will hurt the euro

Sterling has made a decent recovery against the euro in recent weeks, after what was quite a sharp decline as a result of the optimism that followed the announcement of the ECB’s bond-buying plan. There has been a positive response to some of the UK figures that have emerged in recent weeks; trade balance data revealed a dramatic rise in exports to destinations outside the EU, suggesting UK businesses are adapting to deteriorating eurozone demand. Meanwhile, UK unemployment figures continue to defy the overall weak picture of UK economic growth by making significant strides. From retail sales data to public sector borrowing figures, the UK economy has been beating market expectations time and again and this is filtering into some sterling strength. Another positive has emerged with the latest upward revision to the UK’s Q2 GDP figure to -0.4%, considerably better than the original estimate of -0.7%. Hopes are high for a very strong showing for the Q3 UK GDP figure released on October 26.

The minutes from the MPC’S September meeting revealed a unanimous vote against further QE (for now). The decision in favour of leaving the BoE 0.5% base rate unchanged was also unanimous. The fact that one MPC policymaker saw a good case for QE in September did not go unnoticed but as things stand, the Bank of England is understandably in wait-and-see mode. In light of the increased room for domestic optimism and the easing of financial conditions in the eurozone in recent weeks, it will not come as much of a surprise to learn that we are not expecting any fresh monetary easing measures from the Bank of England this month. November is likely to see the Bank assess its options much more carefully though.

Coinciding with strong economic figures has been an increased appetite for the pound as a relative safe-haven. Gilt yields have declined in recent sessions as investors attempt to take cover from renewed uncertainties from the eurozone and as usual this has boosted the pound by association. With the QE decisions from the US Federal Reserve and the Bank of Japan in September, sterling has climbed a little higher up many investors’ wish lists in recent weeks.

Putting improved UK conditions to one side, the major factor behind GBP/EUR’s climb in the past month has been a shift in sentiment against the euro, as is predominantly the case when this pair climbs. The market relief that followed the ECB’s commitment to buy unlimited quantities of distressed peripheral debt has well and truly worn off. Investors have refocused on the major issues facing Spain and Greece in particular.

PM Rajoy has thus far snubbed the opportunity to take advantage of the ECB’s offer to purchase Spanish debt, fully aware of the austerity demands that will accompany such intervention. Rajoy is under enormous pressure domestically, with the rich Catalonia region demanding independence and fierce protests taking place in Madrid over existing austerity measures. The market is likely to have to wait until after regional elections held on October 21 for Rajoy to bite the bullet, which leaves a good three weeks of frustration ahead. That said, if rating agency Moody’s cuts Spain’s credit rating to ‘junk’ status, then a spike in Spanish bond yields could force Rajoy’s hand a little sooner.

Greek saga remains volatile

The situation in Greece also remains typically uncertain. October is an important month too, with some chunky bond repayments maturing. Disagreements not only exist between Greece and the Troika (EU, ECB and IMF) but between the IMF and the EU. With the Greek debt profile blown even further off track by a deeper than expected recession, the IMF is now pushing for another Greek debt restructuring in order to get its debt sustainability back on track. Unsurprisingly, more ‘haircuts’ is not at the top of the EU’s list of priorities.

It looks as if there is some consensus over giving Greece an additional two years to meet its targets and the government appears to have been reached an agreement for €13.5bn in additional spending cuts that they hope will unlock the vital next tranche of aid. However, the agreement still needs Troika approval and would need to be approved by the Greek parliament, which amid violent public protests in Athens is no dead cert. Speculation has surrounded the need for a third Greek bailout but this option looks to be a non-starter as it would require parliamentary approval from individual member states. The bottom line is that Greece may well leave the eurozone but EU leaders are unlikely to let this happen while conditions in Spain remain so tense. The pressure for stronger signs of progress will be turned up once again at the next EU Summit on October 18-19.

Sterling has recouped its mid-September losses against the euro and is back trading above the €1.25 level. With market confidence so shaky at present, any concrete progress - most importantly from Spain in the form of a bailout request – will likely give the euro a significant lift. However, our baseline scenario is that this will not occur and that sentiment will continue to weaken towards the euro, helping sterling to build on its domestic economic resurgence and resume its uptrend against the euro.

GBP/USD

Dollar to strengthen despite QE3

The US Federal Reserve finally pulled the trigger on QE3 in September, which meant it was another very soft month for the US dollar. There have been some bright spots amongst US figures in the past month, with trade balance, retail sales and consumer confidence figures all showing some improvements. However, there has been plenty of evidence of continued economic weakness to support Ben Bernanke’s decision to turn the printing presses back on; last month’s key employment update gave little to cheer about. In addition, the final US GDP figure for Q2 was sharply and unexpectedly revised down to 1.3% from 1.7%.

The issues of weak US economic growth and a long period of quantitative easing are by no means at the top of most investors’ list of concerns. The US dollar has strengthened a little in the past fortnight, amid waning euphoria surrounding the QE3 announcement and the ECB’s pledge to purchase peripheral debt. Spain has not asked for a bailout, Greece has not secured its next tranche of aid and growth across the world is slowing. These are all dollar-friendly factors and the slowdowns being seen in China and the eurozone (including Germany) are of particular concern.

Whilst UK growth data has been remarkably positive in recent weeks, the ongoing fragility of the UK recovery has already been highlighted this week by a weaker than expected manufacturing figure. If sterling is to avoid another short-term sell-off against the US dollar, the UK services figure released on October 3 must be firm. However, sterling should get plenty of support in the form of the preliminary Q3 UK GDP figure released on October 26; we are looking for a robust quarterly showing of around +0.6%.

As things stand, sterling is trading almost two cents below September’s 13-month high of $1.63 and we think this high will remain a ceiling for this pair. Regardless of QE3, we see plenty of scope for increased demand for the safe-haven US dollar. We are still anticipating weakness in the EUR/USD pair, which should send GBP/USD back below $1.60 in October. 

Richard Driver

Currency Analyst

Caxton FX

Market fears reach new heights as Spain edges closer to a sovereign bailout

The bad news for the euro just keeps on flowing. Spanish 10-year bond yields have now risen to a fresh euro-era high above 7.60%, which is a fairly accurate bellwether of market tensions that have built towards Spain and the debt crisis as a whole in recent sessions. Sustained yields above 7.0% pushed Greece, Portugal and Ireland into requesting a bailout and the chances of Spain following suit are rising all the time – another few weeks at current levels and Spain may have no choice but to ask for help.

Meanwhile, German 10-year bonds have recently fallen as low as 1.14%, and 6-month bond yields have even dipped in to negative territory; such is the appetite for safe havens, investors are actually willing to accept losses just to park their funds in the safety of German short-term debt.

The Spanish regional govenrment of Valencia has asked the central government for financial aid, and six other regions including Catalonia and Murcia are expected to do the same. Considering a €100bn bailout was only signed off for Spain’s crumbling bank sector on Friday, these signs of panic from Spain’s regions are the last thing Spanish PM Rajoy needs, particularly as he is trying to quell market fears by insisting that Spain will not require a full-blown sovereign bailout. Spain’s economy minister De Guindos is meeting his German counterpart Schaeuble today and there will be suspicions that a full sovereign bailout will be considered.

The IMF may well be hardening its stance on granting aid to failing eurozone economies, if the rumours of a possible withheld contribution towards Greece’s next aid tranche. So again, these Spanish headlines have come at unfortunate moment.

Spain is continuing to call for intervention from the ECB, De Guindos said on Saturday that "somebody has to bet on the euro and now, given the architecture of Europe isn't changed - who can make this bet but the ECB." If the ECB restarts its programme of buying up distress debt, then Spain can stop paying such high borrowing costs. The ECB has stood firm on this issue for nineteen straight weeks, claiming that the lead on solving the debt crisis should be taken by EU politicians. Stodgy progress in this regard is likely to force the ECB’s hand in the end, particularly as Italy edges closer to disaster.

Spain has major repayments to be made by October, so a full-scale Spanish bailout could well come before then. Amid all these concerns around Spain, Greece is heading towards the exit door, so it should to come as a surprise when we reiterate our bearish view of the euro.

Adam Highfield
Analyst – Caxton FX
For the latest forex news and views, follow us on twitter @caxtonfx and sign up to our daily report.

Caxton FX Weekly Round-up: Euro takes a hammering

ECB cuts rates and the euro takes some punishment

The ECB met expectations last week by cutting the eurozone interest rate to 0.75%. In addition, the deposit rate was cut to zero. This all makes the euro the second-lowest yielding currency in the market after the swiss franc, which is likely to see investors increase their use of the euro as a funding currency for carry trades into higher-yielding currencies. This should be a major factor weighing on the euro moving forward.

For many, the ECB’s rate cut did not go far enough in offering support to the eurozone’s deteriorating situation. There is a significant chance of another interest rate cut at the ECB’s next meeting in August, as there is of alternative easing measures such as another LTRO (cheap loan offering).

The post-EU Summit optimism has well and truly run its course and the market sentiment has once again turned negative. Spanish bond yields are back up at 7.0%, while global equities have tumbled for three days straight. Eurozone investor sentiment data was very poor on Monday morning and with the market already reflecting on recent weak data from the US, Japan and China, the euro has come under some pressure.

It is not all bad news for the euro, however, as we have heard today that Spain will be granted a year’s grace until 2014 to meet its deficit target of 3%. This has been insufficient to trigger any major euro bounce, which is sitting close to 3 ½ year lows against the pound and 2 year lows against the USD.

US data spooks market and risk aversion takes hold

The key monthly figure from the US labour market disappointed last Friday. It is always interesting to see how the US dollar reacts to weak domestic data and Friday’s installment proved supportive of the greenback. Dollar-friendly risk aversion was the knee jerk response, despite the fact that the downtrend in US data is likely to push the US Federal Reserve into finally pulling the trigger with regard to QE3 later this year. There is a chance that the Fed will do so on August 1st and much depends on US data in the intervening period, but we suspect Ben Bernanke & Co will choose to keep their powder dry for another month at least.

The flight to the safety of the US dollar has seen GBP/USD lose some ground in the past few sessions. The Bank of England’s decision to inject another £50B of quantitative easing into the UK’s flat lining economy was broadly priced in, though last week’s poor growth figures from the UK’s construction and services sectors in particular were not helpful for GBP. The week ahead is fairly quiet in terms of domestic data, with only manufacturing production data and trade balance data likely to receive much attention.

EUR/USD was last week’s major mover, having tumbled from above $1.26 to below $1.23 in the space of just three sessions. We have been calling for a slide down towards and below $1.20 and this latest euro sell-off has only strengthened our resolve. GBP/USD fell as well, but not by as much (it fell from $1.57 to $1.55). This cleared the way for GBP/EUR to help itself to some easy gains up above €1.26. These are clearly strong levels at which to buy the euro in the short-term, though in the longer-term we target levels even higher in the direction of €1.30.

The market will look to the meeting of EU finance ministers over the next two days for a decision to activate the buying of peripheral EU debt but as ever there remains plenty of scope for disappointment here.

End of week forecast
GBP / EUR 1.2625
GBP / USD 1.5475
EUR / USD 1.2250
GBP / AUD 1.53

Richard Driver

Analyst – Caxton FX
For the latest forex news and views, follow us on twitter @caxtonfx and sign up to our daily report.

Spanish banks get some help but Greek elections loom

Pressures ease somewhat as Spanish banks receive €100bn bailout

The weekend headlines have revealed that Spain’s banks will be given the support they desperately need through €100bn of emergency EU funding. This is a decent signal of intent from the EU’s leaders; it buys Spain some time and eases concerns surrounding spiraling debt contagion in the eurozone, but it is far from a solution for Spain, never mind the eurozone as a whole. Indeed, the enthusiasm following the weekend’s bailout agreement already appears to have waned.

Growth-wise, eurozone data over the past fortnight has pointed evermore towards a dip back into negative territory in Q2 of 2012. Pressures are still very much being felt in the bond markets, with Spanish 10-year notes yielding almost 6.50% and Italy’s equivalent debt yielding almost 6.00%. Last week’s policy announcement from the ECB was notable in revealing that the central bank is reluctant to cut interest rates from the current 1.00% level. Perhaps more importantly ECB President Draghi is unwilling to step in and buy bonds on the secondary market. The ECB has made it clear that it will not fill the void left by the EU’s dithering leaders.

With Spain’s short-term pressures easing somewhat, the Greek saga comes back into view. This Sunday (June 17th) brings the Greek parliamentary elections, where there remains a significant risk of an anti-bailout coalition emerging. Feasibly, we could see another stalemate and another election called. The situation is incredibly uncertain and looks set to put the market on edge as the event draws closer.

Bank of England decides against QE, for now

Last week saw the Bank of England’s MPC decide against introducing another round of quantitative easing in June. The threat of more QE has been weighing on sterling of late, particularly amid a slew of weak UK growth figures. However, a surprisingly solid UK services figure may well have given some of the MPC policymakers the resolve to hold off on voting for more QE last Thursday. The minutes from the meeting, released next Wednesday, will clearly be very revealing on just how close the MPC’s call on QE was. For now though, sterling looks set to find some favour - it’s safe-haven status should be able to return to the fore as the Greek elections close in.

Elsewhere, US data has continued to point to a slowdown in recent weeks, though Ben Bernanke was unwilling to provide any clues as to the introduction of QE3 any time soon, which is dollar-supportive. He stressed the risks posed by the eurozone debt crisis to the US economy but his rhetoric smacked of a willingness to ‘wait and see.’

Sterling is trading at €1.24, with the euro having totally given back the gains it made on Sunday night as a result of the Spanish bailout progress. Nerves look likely to intensify ahead of the weekend’s Greek elections and as investors contemplate the possibility of a Greek exit from the eurozone once again, we are looking for sterling to climb back up towards €1.25 in the coming sessions.

Likewise we are looking for lower levels for EUR/USD. The euro’s relief rallies are proving more and more flimsy now as the debt crisis goes on. Another look at $1.24 is a distinct possibility, but for now it trades a cent and a half higher. A weaker EUR/USD pair will inevitably weigh on the GBP/USD pair, which currently trades at $1.5530. Whilst we believe sterling should be able to take a decent share of the safe-haven flows this month, we still view anything above $1.55 as a bit lofty.

End of week forecast
GBP / EUR 1.25
GBP / USD 1.5450
EUR / USD 1.2450
GBP / AUD 1.5800

Richard Driver
Analyst – Caxton FX
For the latest forex news and views, follow us on twitter @caxtonfx and sign up to our daily report.

Sterling/Euro June Report

Sterling has continued to rally against the euro in recent weeks, as conditions in the eurozone go from bad to worse. Uncertainty, as ever, is the buzz word. The pro-bailout New Democracy Party has edged ahead in the Greek opinion polls in the past week or so, which has lifted market hopes that the country can receive the additional funding it needs and remain ‘safely’ within the eurozone.  But there is plenty more debate to be had in Greece and few will be truly confident of a positive result ahead of the fresh elections on June 17^th.

The chances of a messy ending to the Greek saga remain very high. Even if a pro-austerity, pro-bailout coalition does emerge out of this month’s elections, they will still have to find a way to deliver the major reforms and deficit reduction that the country’s €130bn bailout agreement requires. The EU Commission reminded Greece earlier this week that its bailout payments remain highly contingent but whoever wins this month’s elections, you can expect some desperate efforts to have the bailout terms relaxed to a significant degree.

Greek concerns, though likely to return to the fore as the elections draw closer, have been put on the back burner for the time-being. True to form, another struggling eurozone nation has stepped up to fill the void – Spain, or more specifically, Spain’s banking sector.  Bankia, Spain’s fourth-largest bank, requires €19bn worth of recapitalisation and it is becoming more and more apparent that Spain will need help to shore up its banking sector. The issue is having a significant impact on Spain’s government borrowing costs, with 10-year bond yields climbing dangerously towards the unsustainable 7.0% level. As ever with this debt crisis, market fears build so much they become a self-fulfilling prophecy. In short, Spain is in very serious trouble and may have to seek external help, which is no small issue given it is the eurozone’s fourth-largest economy and will inevitably turn the market’s gaze towards the third-largest – Italy.

The UK economy is looking particularly downbeat at present, having been hit with the confirmation that it is firmly in double-dip recession territory. Unsurprisingly, consumer confidence has taken a sharp downturn. April’s growth data from the services and manufacturing sectors was poor and a gauge of UK retail sales showed the worst figure in almost four years. The last update from the UK labour market was a little more encouraging but we will need to see more than one good month before hoping for sustained improvements.

Amid all of this bad domestic economic news, as well as the grave threats posed by the eurozone debt crisis, it might be assumed that more quantitative easing is bound to be introduced by the Bank of England in order to drag the UK out of recession. Certainly the IMF has made its views known on the issue, encouraging the BoE to act soon to safeguard the UK economy.

However, the noises out of the MPC have not suggested that such a move is imminent, despite the recent sharp decline UK inflation from 3.5% to 3.0%. A key reason for this is that the BoE sees UK inflation in the medium term as equally likely to exceed its 2.0% target as undershoot it.  In addition, Spencer Dale has recently stressed the argument that the recent quantitative easing doses are still feeding through to provide stimulus and that a further round is not appropriate at present. This position is supported by the recent improvement in UK money growth.

With only one MPC policymaker voting in favour of QE at the MPC’s May meeting, in the form of David Miles, there is plenty of dovish recruitment to be done in the coming months if the BoE is to pull the trigger again on further monetary easing. Sterling seems safe in this regard for June at least, though eurozone risks could feasibly escalate sufficiently to prompt BoE action in July or August.  

So, despite the UK economy sitting uncomfortably in a double-dip recession and facing a prolonged period of period of stagnant growth and ultra-low interest rates, sterling looks free to continue taking advantage of an increasingly euro-negative environment. Sterling/Euro climbed a further two cents in May, leaving this pair with gains over 4.0% in the past two months. We envisage further gains for the relative safe-haven pound in June, with the Greek elections and rising Spanish bond yields providing plenty of motivation to exit the euro.

Richard Driver
Analyst – Caxton FX

For the latest forex news and views, follow us on twitter @caxtonfx and sign up to our daily report.

Portugal passes bailout review - aid tranche to be released

The main news this morning was that Portugal is to recieve its next €14.6bn tranche of aid under last year's bailout agreement, having passed the Troik's assessment. 

The market’s response has been fairly muted but it is definitely relieving news from Portugal.

The Iberian country is clearly next on the market’s ‘hit list’ and this next tranche is essential for eurozone confidence in the short-term. It staves off fears that Portugal is destined to follow the same path as Greece.

Portugal is making the right noises in ruling out the need for further aid but the market is very much in wait and see mode now, the cynics will say they’ve heard it all before.

Ireland has shown that aggressive reforms can actually work and return countries to competitiveness, so there is a precedent to follow there.

The OECD’s research shows that the periphery are actually working hard on their reforms, the problem is it can take a long time for all of the benefits to emerge, time the markets aren’t necessarily willing to grant countries like Portugal.

It will be interesting to see if tomorrow’s 3-year LTRO from the ECB relieves some of the pressure on Portuguese bond yields. Portuguese yields actually increased since mid-December’s LTRO and you’d assume they will be left out in the cold this time, which is a major concern.

Richard Driver
Caxton FX Analyst

Weekly Analysis: Euro still looking vulnerable

Early year optimism disappears very quickly

There were signs of a rally in confidence and risk appetite in the session or so of 2012 but sentiment quickly deteriorated due to all the familiar eurozone-related concerns. Poor demand at eurozone bond auctions (including that of Germany, much to the market’s concern) and widening yield spreads saw the euro resume its downtrend almost across the board. Linked to this are ongoing concerns of blanket downgrades throughout the eurozone when Standard & Poor’s decides to take action. There are plenty of bond auctions this week to keep the euro under pressure; Greece will look to the market on Tuesday, while Italy and Spain will do so on Thursday.

Also in the headlines in recent sessions has been the worsening economic picture in the eurozone. EU leaders finally appear to be willing to address the issue of eurozone growth. The debt crisis is having such as impact on confidence that the region is spiralling into recession and EU leaders have earmarked the Jan 30th meeting as an opportunity to look at eurozone growth and the region’s soaring unemployment levels (10.3% for the eurozone).

Figures last week revealed a eurozone services sector contraction, as well as negative monthly growth in both German and eurozone retail sales. Forward looking data such as German factory and eurozone industrial orders also undershot expectations last week. It seems businesses on the continent are preparing for the worst and sitting on their capital. With the lack of leadership we have seen on the debt issue, it is difficult to question why.

Merkel and Sarkozy’s meeting produced little of real note; they remain committed to the progress made on introducing greater budgetary discipline in the eurozone and continue to urge Greece to reach an agreement with private bondholders on haircuts before the country is given its 2nd bailout.

The ECB will have its monthly meeting and press conference on Thursday, which will surely overshadow the BoE’s Monetary Policy Committee meeting. We think there is a greater chance of another ECB rate cut than the market is currently appreciating. Eurozone data is only going one way and with inflation also beginning to ease, Draghi could well pull the trigger for the third consecutive month. That said, we are still betting that the ECB will keep its powder dry for this month, though another cut in Q1 is almost a dead cert.

UK growth takes a more positive turn, but for how long?

Last week’s monthly set of UK growth data take a turn for the better, with each of the services, manufacturing and construction sector figures beating expectations. The services sector was particularly impressive in December.

The outlook for the UK recovery remains highly uncertain and risks are firmly fixed to the downside. Sterling should benefit nonetheless, with hopes being raised that the Bank of England may be convinced that further quantitative easing may not be necessary after all. High demand for UK debt continues to support the pound; gilts were the top performing government bond for 2011 and are starting 2012 where they spent the last.

Sterling is trading up at a sixteen month high of 1.21 against the euro and the outlook is looking very strong for GBP/EUR. Less so against the dollar, the US recovery is gathering pace at an impressive rate, which is only adding to the safe-haven appeal of the greenback. GBP/USD is trading just above a four month low of $1.54.

End of week forecast:

GBP / EUR 1.2150
GBP / USD 1.54
EUR / USD 1.27
GBP / AUD 1.51

Richard Driver
Analyst – Caxton FX
For the latest forex news and views, follow us on twitter @caxtonfx and sign up to our daily report.

So how will the market respond to today’s eurozone plans?

Today’s EU Summit will be covering a range of issues, top of the list are the recapitalisation of Europe’s banks, the expansion of the EFSF (bailout fund) and the haircuts to be imposed on Greek debt. The meeting has been the sole focus of the market for the past fortnight.

There was already disappointing news yesterday that a meeting between EU finance ministers scheduled today has been cancelled due to a lack of agreement, though the main meeting between EU leaders is set to go ahead. Expectations for progress have been heightened; market confidence in EU leadership remains palpably lifted it seems. Though all the tell-tale signs of delay and disagreement point to the strong possibility of a fudged and inadequate compromise being delivered today.

It would be surprising if the EU Summit failed to deliver something that represented a decent attempt at “comprehensive package.” Many will be betting that the euro stands to benefit from any signs of genuine progress on the eurozone’s severe economic and fiscal woes. However, we are betting that the euro will suffer a slide. First, there is a strong chance that the package could fail to meet market expectations. Second, the package could be impressive, but the market may well take “buy the rumour, sell the fact” approach and choose to take profit on the euro’s gains this month.

We know one thing for sure, today’s EU Summit will leave plenty of details to be ironed out, plenty of obstacles to be overcome, and plenty of issues unresolved. These are factors that could see the euro sell-off in the immediate aftermath of tomorrow’s Summit, or alternatively once the dust settles. Either way, the euro looks a little strong at €1.15 and $1.39 and we are looking for a downward correction for the euro.

Richard Driver
Analyst – Caxton FX
For the latest forex news and views, follow us on twitter @caxtonfx and sign up to our daily report.

Delay is hurting the euro.

Shares in Italy’s biggest bank, Unicredit Spa, lost 7.9 percent on what the Italian media have dubbed “Black Friday,” a day which saw a large sell-off in Italian assets. Unicredit Spa, along with several other banks, witnessed a sharp drop in the stock market caused largely by worries about the results of stress tests of European banks, the results of which will be released on July 15th. Friday’s market sell-off has increased fears that Italy, the third largest economy in the euro zone, could be the next to suffer in the debt crisis. This brings major concern to the ECB as the euro zone’s current rescue mechanism, the EFSF, would have insufficient funds to help should Italian bond yields continue to rise and put heavy pressure on Italy’s finances.


A gathering of the European Union’s top finance officials in Brussels on Monday is being described as a “coordination, not a crisis meeting.” Despite Herman Van Rompuy’s (president of the European Council) spokesman claiming that Italy will not be on the agenda, it seems impossible that the situation in Italy will not be discussed in Van Rompuy’s meeting with ECB President Jean-Claude Trichet and Jean-Claude Juncker, chairman of the Eurogroup and a few more.

This small meeting of EU finance officials comes ahead of a larger meeting of the 17 euro zone ministers this afternoon which will focus mainly on discussion of the private sector’s involvement in a second bailout package for Greece. Germany, Austria, Finland and the Netherlands are the main advocates in pushing for banks, insurers and other private holders of Greek bonds to shoulder up to a quarter of the bailout package, but after two weeks of negotiations with bankers, very little progress has been made on a plan agreeable to all sides.

The latest proposal that seems to be gaining credence is a plan which would swap Greek bonds for longer-dated debt that would extend maturities by seven years. However, this would likely be seen as a default by ratings agencies while both ECB and German officials stick tight to their claims that they will not accept any plan that is regarded a default.

Another idea that has been floated around, but would essentially mean euro zone finance ministers’ accepting a Greek default, is a buy-back system in which the EFSF bailout fund would buy Greek bonds from the market and retire them. Another major problem with this idea is that it would require changes to the EFSF’s rules, so it would have to pass through national parliaments.

A key issue in all of this is time. Although Greece says it doesn’t need the bailout until early September, euro zone officials see it necessary to get a deal done within the next couple of weeks as any further delay could weigh heavily on investor confidence in the region. As for the euro, speed is definitely of the essence. It has declined by over two cents against the dollar, and by almost a cent against the pound.

Matt Abraham
Caxton FX
 
For the latest forex news and views, follow us on twitter @caxtonfx and sign up to our daily report.

Peripheral debt issues finally hit the euro...hard.

The euro is being sold off by the bucket load today. German ministers have claimed that Greece is unlikely to make it through the summer without defaulting. Success for the euro-sceptic True Finns party in the Finnish parliamentary elections has created further uncertainty around the recent Portuguese bailout request. Moody’s rating agency has also downgraded Irish debt to junk status today. All this on what was supposed to be a relatively quiet session!

Investors have been spooked by reports from the Greek media that Greece recently told the EU and the IMF that it wanted to restructure its debt. The story was denied by officials in Athens, but the damage had already been done.

Should such an event occur, it would be the first debt restructuring in the EU’s fairly brief history, which in the absence of precedent carries with it very real concerns. If Greece defaults, who would bet against Portugal and Ireland defaulting? Spanish debt has held up fairly well in the wake of the Portuguese bailout request, but contagion to Portugal’s Iberian counterpart remains a constant threat.

BBC business editor Robert Peston’s blog on Friday noted the risks of peripheral defaults to Germany. The German economy is performing robustly at present, but the German banking system is actually quite vulnerable, and Peston’s point about their exposure to peripheral debt is a good one. A debt restructuring would mean a haircut for creditors like German banks, so the German people should be careful about toughening up on its struggling eurozone friends!

As a result of today’s news, the euro has fallen sharply across the board. Against the dollar, the single currency has fallen by nearly 1.5%, and almost 1% against sterling. Asian sovereign buyers have been very willing to buy on euro dips, and have also been particularly resilient to eurozone debt issues in recent months.

We expect euro will find some support in the Asian session, though recouping all of today’s losses will require a serious show of faith.

Richard Driver
Analyst – Caxton FX
For the latest forex news and views, follow us on twitter @caxtonfx and sign up to our daily report.

Should Portugal just bite the bullet and seek annexation by Brazil...?

So suggests an interesting article on the Financial Times website today.

The context: The current strength of the euro reveals that the markets are not overly concerned with the Portuguese debt crisis at present, or indeed with the eurozone debt problems in general. This remains the case despite almost daily news of credit downgrades to peripheral nations; most recently Greece and Portugal. With a decision on the EU bailout fund delayed until June, the debt crisis is unlikely to be resolved any time soon.

The unstable fiscal situation in Portugal is so bad that an interview on the Financial Times website mooted a highly controversial solution. It was argued that Brazil, Portugal’s former colony, should annex the struggling Iberian state. Portugal is a very low growth, high deficit economy with major governmental issues (currently doesn’t have one!). Brazil’s economy, by contrast, is set to boom again this year and is so large (in total GDP at least, not per capita) it could accommodate Portugal’s substantial and crippling debt with little trouble.

Granted, the comment was ‘tongue-in-cheek’ and was clearly designed to provoke a reaction. Such a solution is totally unprecedented and quite plainly there is no willingness from either nation to allow such a dilution to their national identities.

Nonetheless, the interview did treat the Portuguese issue with the urgency it warrants, and with the urgency we see returning to the markets. Our bet is that as soon as next week’s ECB rate rise is a thing of the past, market sentiment towards the debt issue will worsen and weigh on the euro accordingly. Already borrowing costs in the periphery are unsustainable; throwing in a 0.25% rise in the base interest rate is only going to send costs higher.

Richard Driver
Analyst – Caxton FX

For the latest forex news and views, follow us on twitter @caxtonfx and sign up to our daily report.

Ongoing cause for eurozone concern but sterling/euro levels set to remain until April 7th

In the wake of the EU Summit last week, and further eurozone developments over the weekend, now is a good time to discuss how on earth the euro can be performing so strongly and how long we can expect this continue.

At present the euro is trading at a five-month high against sterling, and is continuing to hold above the key $1.40 level against the US dollar, just 1.4% from its recent high reached early last week. This strong performance has seen the single currency shake off a series of peripheral debt and bank downgrades, record-high Portuguese bond yields on the back of the country’s government collapse, and ongoing concerns over the region’s bailout fund.

Why such resilience? The key attraction to the euro is that the ECB is due to raise its base interest rate on April 7th, well ahead of a June (at the earliest) BoE rate rise and an expected 2012 Fed rate rise. In addition, the euro is continuing to benefit from solid Eastern sovereign commitment to diversify reserves via the euro. For the time being the markets appear confident that the German and French economies are strong enough to pull the eurozone through the worst-case scenarios in the periphery. Ahead of April 7th, we doubt that the single currency will come under any prolonged pressure. However, it could well prove to be a turning point.

Following the ECB rate rise, the market may refocus its attention on Portugal and the lack of progress being made towards an underlying resolution. The EU Summit was marked as a deadline for the eurozone bailout issue, but this decision has now been delayed until June. Market disappointment was actually muted to this delay but frustration could yet re-emerge. In addition, over the weekend German Chancellor Angela Merkel lost another key regional election; if this is repeated and the markets lose confidence in German political resolve to spearhead eurozone debt aid, then much of the single currency’s recent appreciation could be ceded.

We are still sterling-positive on a longer-term view, though recent UK economic data may delay improvements in the rate.

As for the US dollar, a change in rhetoric from the Fed in response to higher-than-expected fourth quarter economic growth may have improved the currency’s outlook. It was indicated that the Fed will definitely be ending QE2 in June (and perhaps earlier…), though no indications have been made as to an earlier-than-expected Fed rate rise. Unless a Fed rate rise is brought forward to this year, we do not foresee a strong dollar performance even with an increasingly positive US economic outlook.

Richard Driver
Analyst – Caxton FX


For the latest forex news and views, follow us on twitter @caxtonfx and sign up to our daily report.

MPC Minutes dishearten investors but high hopes for change were misplaced

After a long time out of the spotlight, the UK again took prominence today as the minutes from the MPC’s March meeting were released this morning. In addition, we saw Chancellor George Osborne announce the UK’s 2011 budget earlier today. The former caught the eye but the latter left the market unperturbed.

Central bank interest rates are the real market-mover at present and an insight into policymakers’ views will always attract attention. The minutes revealed that Andrew Sentance’s hawkish camp failed to coax a fourth MPC member to join their campaign to increase interest rates. Had they succeeded in this, the outlook for a BoE rate rise as early as May would have been greatly improved, particularly in light of yesterday’s appalling UK inflation figures (4.4%!).

On release of the news, sterling dropped sharply across the board, and investors may well have been disappointed by the lack of any real increase in hawkish language adopted within the minutes. Indeed if anything, the tone reflected additional uncertainty following recent global developments, which will likely cloud the UK’s economic outlook.

Osborne’s budget announcement today contained a wide range of interesting material; the headline was probably Osborne’s downward revision of the UK’s growth forecast for 2011 to 1.7% (from 2.1% - itself an already downwardly revised estimate) but sterling has survived this hit relatively unscathed.

Sterling has actually lost little ground to the euro today as some bad news from the eurozone irritated the markets. It has been announced that the EU Summit this weekend will not be reaching a final decision on the ever-troublesome bailout fund. Given that the markets had grown in enthusiasm after initial progress at a preliminary summit, and that they would get a definitive answer this Friday, the delay of the decision until June seems to have frustrated euro-investors. Concerns have also mounted with regard to the Portuguese Parliament’s vote on its government’s austerity measures, which if rejected will almost certainly see its PM resign, and could well be the catalyst for a Portuguese bailout.

At present, sterling remains in limbo around €1.15 with another trigger needed to define direction.

Richard Driver
Analyst – Caxton FX


For the latest forex news and views, follow us on twitter @caxtonfx and sign up to our daily report.

Crunch Time: EU Summit

Next Friday’s EU Summit marks a self-imposed deadline for eurozone leaders to reach an agreement on a “comprehensive package” to deal with the region’s fiscal problems. Progress was made earlier than expected at the preliminary Summit last weekend, and the markets responded positively – perhaps too positively if Trichet’s recent pessimistic comments are anything to go by.

Most significantly, EU leaders reached an agreement to expand the European Financial Stability Fund (EFSF). However, the more realistic tones coming out of the Summit are stressing that “the devil is in the detail” and whilst broad principles were agreed, the financial technicalities involved in actually implementing those principles pose a huge obstacle to concrete commitments.

Certainly, the enlarged bailout fund is a step in the right direction but it is more difficult for the EU member states to agree in what proportions they should contribute. One would assume larger states such as France and Germany would shoulder the burden but their national publics are growing tired of this ‘duty.’ Another issue surrounds the continuation of the ECB’s bond-buying role instead of allowing the EFSF to buy bonds on the secondary market, which Trichet feels particularly aggrieved about. Superseding all of this is the fact that the EFSF is set to expire in 2013, with the European Stability Mechanism to replace it, so agreement on the shape of this longer-term fund is paramount next week.

Coming into this month, the markets were cynical as to progress on EU debt issues. However, with Trichet turning up the heat on EU leaders (indicating borrowing costs would be increased in April with an ECB interest rate hike) we saw greater political commitment last weekend and increased market confidence followed. The euro has strengthened against the US dollar and sterling accordingly, despite several recent peripheral credit downgrades and very high bond yields.

It is possible that agreement on a “comprehensive package” next week will trigger a strong euro rally next week, persuading the markets that the eurozone debt problem can finally be put to rest. More likely though, in this risk adverse environment, is that the markets will greet an agreement positively but remain broadly cautious on the euro. Any gains will be incremental as markets await further proof that the situations in Portugal, Spain and Greece will improve. Sterling is likely to suffer against the single currency if the Summit is successful, at least in the short term, given that the ECB is almost certain to raise interest rates before the BoE. However, the pound should continue to outperform the US dollar, tracking euro strength.

Richard Driver
Analyst – Caxton FX


For the latest forex news and views, follow us on twitter @caxtonfx and sign up to our daily report.

Market Volatility Explained

The beginning of 2011 has thrown up a series of major market-moving events and we thought it’d be useful to take a closer look at the extent to which localised unrest and disasters can send shockwaves through the currency markets, and why. After all, how many of you would expect that the Norwegian Kroner will directly benefit from social uprisings in Bahrain? (Norway is a major oil producer, Middle Eastern tensions push oil prices up, Norway profits.)

Whilst the currency markets are more volatile than, for example the equity markets, in calmer times even currency movements can be relatively predictable. When the market spotlight is focused on economic fundamentals, data announcements have a direct impact and exchange rates are more faithful to trends. In early 2011, we saw sentiment governed by interest rate speculation and sterling benefited accordingly whilst the greenback suffered.

However, such factors are of little relevance to investors during times of uncertainty. Most recently the Japanese crisis, but before this the natural disasters in Australia and New Zealand, and unrest throughout the Middle East and North Africa, place traditional economic factors on the backburner. Long-term investors flee to the safety of currencies such as the Swiss franc, the US dollar and the Japanese yen. Short-term investors, or “speculators,” react so quickly to events that their movement is as unpredictable as the freak occurrences on which they base their currency “bets.”

Using the Swiss franc as an example, market volatility surrounding natural disasters is clearly visible in the context of the Japanese earthquake/tsunami/nuclear crisis, and is clearly visible. The “swissie” climbed 6 cents against the Australian dollar from 1.06 to 1.12 in the space of 3 days, having hovered around the 1.06 mark for the preceding three weeks. Investors abandon calculated risks on currencies such as the aussie, euro and sterling, and revert back to safety in such uncertain times leading to sharp appreciation of “safer” currencies such as the Swiss franc.

We can be confident that these times of heightened volatility will prove temporary. As events stabilise in states such as Bahrain and Japan the market’s will begin to calm down and factors such as interest rate differentials and growth potential will return to focus, bringing with them more predictable currency investments. However, amid soaring debt levels in eurozone peripheral countries, there may yet be another crisis round the corner unless the EU can reach a firm agreement at their Summit meeting next week.

Richard Driver
Analyst – Caxton FX


For the latest forex news and views, follow us on twitter @caxtonfx and sign up to our daily report.

The Tobin Tax: Will they, Won’t they?

Yesterday, the European Parliament (EP) voted to pass the Tobin Tax, otherwise known as the Robin Hood Tax. The tax proposal represents a 0.05% levy on all financial transaction passing through the EU and it is estimated that it will raise €200bn annually. Whilst the EP may have backed the proposals, the measure will not come into force until it is passed by national legislatures. Herein lies the main obstacle...

Is it a good idea? Well in theory it’s certainly a nice idea. Banks would barely notice the impact of the levy and it would reduce exchange rate volatility caused by short-termism, but the fund could also be used to ease global poverty and the effects of climate change. 

However, although the tax is appealing the pitfalls are glaring. The tax is likely to have the damaging effect of reducing liquidity in the FX markets as speculative investors would turn elsewhere. The EU wants to press ahead with EU-wide coordination of the levy if a worldwide tax proves too difficult to attain (as surely it will). However, in light of this the tax would simply be unenforceable as EU financial centres would be a far less attractive place for banks to do business. Inevitably major institutions would relocate en-masse to more tax-friendly centres, taking with them a vital source of income for the EU. 

Nonetheless, France and Germany are right behind the tax, and accuse the UK of “dragging its feet” on the issue. London is the global financial centre of the world and Britain’s economy is heavily reliant on the financial services industry. Banks relocating is a heated enough debate as it is so can we blame George Osborne & Co for balking at the prospect of adding yet another tax?  

It seems highly likely that, despite the renewed energy the EU is putting behind it, the Tobin Tax will not gain the widespread approval that such a measure requires. Whilst so-called “banker bashing” is an excellent way for political leaders to bolster their own popularity, the Tobin Tax reeks of over-ambition and impracticality. And as for “banker bashing,” don’t be fooled by the label of “Robin Hood Tax,” the burden that the tax will impose on the banks will, as ever, simply be passed on to the consumer, so be careful what you wish for…

Richard Driver

Analyst – Caxton FX

For the latest forex news and views, follow us on twitter @caxtonfx and sign up to our daily report.