Thursday, 14 June 2012

Scottish Independence - the Currency Dilemma

The ‘Yes Scotland’ campaign – the campaign for Scottish independence - is gathering pace and it brings with it some interesting currency-related questions.

Scottish independence is by no means imminent - the referendum is not scheduled until the autumn of 2014 - but there is plenty of debate to be had. Scotland’s First Minister Alex Salmond has certainly put his and the weight of his Scottish Nationalist Party firmly behind the cause. However, there is plenty of support for keeping Scotland within the UK; a pro-union campaign is expected to be launched in the coming months. Indeed, a recent poll commissioned by Scottish MP Alistair Darling revealed that only 33% of those surveyed were in favour of independence, whilst 57% opposed it and 10% were undecided.

In 2006, Salmond endorsed the idea of the “arc of prosperity,” where Scotland joined a Nordic Union made up of wealthy smaller Northern European nations of Iceland, Ireland and Norway. Joining the euro seems a little more likely.

Salmond has said that Scotland could eventually join the euro, after a referendum was held on the issue. However, this is becoming a decreasingly attractive prospect given the escalation of the debt crisis over the past year or so.

Leading economist Professor Garelli, former MD of the World Economic Forum, has argued that an independent Scotland will have no choice but to join the euro. Garelli cited the euro’s world reserve currency status and the benefits this brings with commodity trading and making the most of North Sea oil.

There are some interesting arguments suggesting that Scottish independence would require a reapplication to become a member of the EU, and new members of the EU are expected to join the euro as a matter of course. Interpretation of the European Community Treaty may well have to be played out in the courts- it comes down to whether Scotland would continue to benefit from the UK’s special dispensation to opt out of the euro whilst remaining in the EU.

The development of the eurozone debt crisis makes it quite hard to believe that the Scottish population will want to join that particular party. Certainly, 2014 leaves plenty of time for conditions to change, but progress in the debt crisis has proved remarkably slow. Joining the euro would seem to be a long-term plan, very long-term. SNP Finance Minister Swinney has cited the mid-2020s as a possible euro-entry date. By this point, EU integration is likely to be so far down the line that the notion of any genuine Scottish independence within the euro could be laughable.

The SNP has made it clear that its current position is for Scotland to keep the pound in the short-term, and importantly, retaining the backing of the Bank of England. It goes without saying that Scotland would want to maintain access to the Bank of England as a lender of last-resort (a backstop), should any of its financial institutions hit panic-stations. Scotland would like to combine this with fiscal independence, but this would equate to the BoE signing blank cheques. It is impossible to believe that Scotland will be allowed to pick and chose in such a way. So this raises the question of just how independent Scotland can be if it retains the pound. This is a question which the SNP are struggling to cope with.

Richard Driver

Analyst – Caxton FX
For the latest forex news and views, follow us on twitter @caxtonfx and sign up to our daily report.

Monday, 11 June 2012

Spanish banks get some help but Greek elections loom

Pressures ease somewhat as Spanish banks receive €100bn bailout

The weekend headlines have revealed that Spain’s banks will be given the support they desperately need through €100bn of emergency EU funding. This is a decent signal of intent from the EU’s leaders; it buys Spain some time and eases concerns surrounding spiraling debt contagion in the eurozone, but it is far from a solution for Spain, never mind the eurozone as a whole. Indeed, the enthusiasm following the weekend’s bailout agreement already appears to have waned.

Growth-wise, eurozone data over the past fortnight has pointed evermore towards a dip back into negative territory in Q2 of 2012. Pressures are still very much being felt in the bond markets, with Spanish 10-year notes yielding almost 6.50% and Italy’s equivalent debt yielding almost 6.00%. Last week’s policy announcement from the ECB was notable in revealing that the central bank is reluctant to cut interest rates from the current 1.00% level. Perhaps more importantly ECB President Draghi is unwilling to step in and buy bonds on the secondary market. The ECB has made it clear that it will not fill the void left by the EU’s dithering leaders.

With Spain’s short-term pressures easing somewhat, the Greek saga comes back into view. This Sunday (June 17th) brings the Greek parliamentary elections, where there remains a significant risk of an anti-bailout coalition emerging. Feasibly, we could see another stalemate and another election called. The situation is incredibly uncertain and looks set to put the market on edge as the event draws closer.

Bank of England decides against QE, for now

Last week saw the Bank of England’s MPC decide against introducing another round of quantitative easing in June. The threat of more QE has been weighing on sterling of late, particularly amid a slew of weak UK growth figures. However, a surprisingly solid UK services figure may well have given some of the MPC policymakers the resolve to hold off on voting for more QE last Thursday. The minutes from the meeting, released next Wednesday, will clearly be very revealing on just how close the MPC’s call on QE was. For now though, sterling looks set to find some favour - it’s safe-haven status should be able to return to the fore as the Greek elections close in.

Elsewhere, US data has continued to point to a slowdown in recent weeks, though Ben Bernanke was unwilling to provide any clues as to the introduction of QE3 any time soon, which is dollar-supportive. He stressed the risks posed by the eurozone debt crisis to the US economy but his rhetoric smacked of a willingness to ‘wait and see.’

Sterling is trading at €1.24, with the euro having totally given back the gains it made on Sunday night as a result of the Spanish bailout progress. Nerves look likely to intensify ahead of the weekend’s Greek elections and as investors contemplate the possibility of a Greek exit from the eurozone once again, we are looking for sterling to climb back up towards €1.25 in the coming sessions.

Likewise we are looking for lower levels for EUR/USD. The euro’s relief rallies are proving more and more flimsy now as the debt crisis goes on. Another look at $1.24 is a distinct possibility, but for now it trades a cent and a half higher. A weaker EUR/USD pair will inevitably weigh on the GBP/USD pair, which currently trades at $1.5530. Whilst we believe sterling should be able to take a decent share of the safe-haven flows this month, we still view anything above $1.55 as a bit lofty.

End of week forecast
GBP / EUR 1.25
GBP / USD 1.5450
EUR / USD 1.2450
GBP / AUD 1.5800

Richard Driver
Analyst – Caxton FX
For the latest forex news and views, follow us on twitter @caxtonfx and sign up to our daily report.

Thursday, 7 June 2012

UK services sector growth solid and BoE holds fire on QE

This morning’s figure from the UK services sector was solid, coming in at 53.3, the same as in May but well above expectations. The figure is nothing to get too excited about but it is certainly a relief to see that the UK services sector remains firmly in expansion territory, even if the UK economy as a whole is contracting slightly.

One point to consider here is that these PMI surveys have lost a little bit of credibility given the positive surveys that characterised Q1, only for a -0.3% GDP figure to be announced. Nonetheless, the PMI surveys will remain significant as long as the MPC places such emphasis upon them.

Warmer weather and expectations for increased activity relating to the Jubilee and the Olympics helped stave off a services sector decline in May but weakness in the UK manufacturing sector remains the major concern with respect to the UK economy at present. Last week’s manufacturing PMI figure was very poor indeed.

The Bank of England’s monetary policy decision for June was announced at noon today, revealing a ‘no’ vote on further quantitative easing, for now. This morning’s UK services figure will have eased some of the pressure being felt by some of the MPC members to vote in favour of QE. Today’s monetary policy decision is likely to have been a closer call than in previous meetings. Judging by sterling’s rally in the aftermath of the decision, many market players had been suspicious of a June QE call over the past week or so. Nonetheless, we were not expecting them to pull the trigger again today.


The sounds out of the MPC just haven’t been dovish enough to indicate another round of easing was imminent, though the weak UK data over recent weeks arguably would have justified it. The MPC is probably holding more QE back as a fire extinguisher if the worst case scenario emerges from the eurozone debt crisis. The majority of the MPC seems content that the last round of QE is still feeding through and providing stimulus, they look happy to wait and see for now. In terms of inflation, the balances of risks on the medium term outlook remain equal, thus making any fine-tuning less attractive.

As ever, the minutes in a fortnight will be all-important – David Miles will clearly have voted for more QE and Posen is likely to have joined him, all eyes will be on the rest of the voters.

Richard Driver
Analyst – Caxton FX
For the latest forex news and views, follow us on twitter @caxtonfx and sign up to our daily report.

Wednesday, 6 June 2012

Doom and gloom on the domestic front but GBP remains popular

The perpetual threat to the global financial system that is Greece has dominated the headlines in recent weeks. The country’s May 6th elections saw the ruling pro-bailout coalition fail to secure sufficient support from Greece’s angry electorate. This ushered in a month of huge uncertainty as the market looked ahead to another Greek election on June 17th; with speculation growing that Greece’s anti-bailout parties would curry enough favour to form a coalition. The logical result of a rejection of Greece’s second bailout agreement would be default and an exit from the euro, so it should come as no surprise that the euro suffered further declines.

The pound was a key beneficiary of these euro declines, despite the negative implications that the eurozone debt crisis has on the already dire state of the UK economy. Recent data not only confirmed that the UK entered a double-dip recession in Q1, but it contracted by 0.3% rather than the 0.2% initially estimated. Taken with April and May’s growth figures, which are pointing to a soft start to Q2, this has unsurprisingly triggered fresh speculation that the MPC will edge back towards introducing more quantitative easing in the second half of the year. We are doubtful in this regard, for now.

Sterling is trading at impressive levels against the euro and despite a period of profit-taking in the past week or so, it remains at strong levels against the majority of global currencies thanks to its safe-haven, euro-alternative tag. However, as usual there is one currency sterling can’t outperform in the strongly risk averse trading conditions that characterised most of May – the US dollar. The dollar has helped itself to some easy and significant gains across the board as the eurozone debt crisis forces market players to unwind their riskier positions in favour of the safest of assets.

GBP/EUR

Sterling remains firm and continues to threaten higher climbs against the euro, as conditions in the eurozone go from bad to worse. Uncertainty, as ever, is the buzz word. The pro-bailout New Democracy Party has edged ahead in the Greek opinion polls, which has lifted market hopes that the country can receive the additional funding it needs and remain ‘safely’ within the eurozone. But there is plenty more debate to be had in Greece and few will be truly confident of a positive result ahead of the fresh elections on June 17th. Yet another Greek election is a distinct possibility.

The chances of a messy ending to the Greek saga remain very high. Even if a pro-austerity, pro-bailout coalition does emerge out of this month’s elections, they will still have to find a way to deliver the major reforms and deficit reduction that the country’s €130bn bailout agreement requires – no mean feat. The EU Commission has recently reminded Greece that its bailout payments remain highly contingent but whoever wins this month’s elections, you can expect some desperate efforts to have the bailout terms relaxed to a significant degree.

Spain rings alarm bells

Greek concerns, though likely to return to the fore as the elections draw closer, have been put on the back burner for the time-being. True to form, another struggling eurozone nation has stepped up to fill the void – Spain, or more specifically, Spain’s banking sector. Bankia, Spain’s fourth-largest bank, requires €19bn worth of recapitalisation and it is becoming more and more apparent that Spain will need help to shore up its banking sector as a whole. The issue is having a significant impact on Spain’s government borrowing costs, with 10-year bond yields climbing dangerously towards the unsustainable 7.0% level.

As ever with this debt crisis, market fears build so much that they tend to become a self-fulfilling prophecy. In short, Spain is in very serious trouble and its government has admitted as much – requesting EU help with bank capitalisation. This is no minor development given that Spain is the eurozone’s fourth-largest economy and emergency help for Spain will inevitably turn the market’s gaze towards the third-largest – Italy.

UK economy still looks frail

The UK economy is looking particularly downbeat at present, having been hit with the confirmation that it is firmly in double-dip recession territory. Unsurprisingly, consumer confidence has taken a sharp downturn and weakness in UK growth figures has become alarmingly consistent. The last update from the UK labour market was a little more encouraging but we will need to see more than one good month before hoping for sustained improvements.

Amid all of this bad domestic economic news, as well as the grave threats posed by the eurozone debt crisis, it might be assumed that more quantitative easing is bound to be introduced by the Bank of England in order to drag the UK out of recession. Certainly the IMF has made its views known on the issue, encouraging the BoE to act soon to safeguard the UK economy.

However, the noises out of the MPC have not suggested that such a move is imminent, despite the recent sharp decline UK inflation from 3.5% to 3.0%. A key reason for this is that the BoE sees UK inflation in the medium term as equally likely to exceed its 2.0% target as undershoot it. In addition, Spencer Dale has recently stressed the argument that the recent quantitative easing doses are still feeding through to provide stimulus and that a further round is not appropriate at present. This position is supported by the recent improvement in UK money growth.

With only one MPC policymaker voting in favour of QE at the MPC’s May meeting, in the form of David Miles, there is plenty of dovish recruitment to be done in the coming months if the BoE is to pull the trigger again on further monetary easing. Sterling seems safe in this regard for June at least, though eurozone risks could feasibly escalate sufficiently to prompt BoE action in July or August.

Euro to weaken further

So, despite the UK economy sitting uncomfortably in a double-dip recession and facing a prolonged period of stagnant growth and ultra-low interest rates, sterling looks free to continue taking advantage of an increasingly euro-negative environment. Some major steps towards EU fiscal union will be required to ease market sentiment, and the obstacles to this are all too clear.

Sterling/euro hit heights of €1.2575 in mid-May but has come off those highs to the current level of €1.24. We envisage further gains for the relative safe-haven pound in June, with the Greek elections and rising Spanish bond yields providing plenty of motivation to exit the euro. €1.26 is a realistic target in the coming few weeks.

GBP/USD

Whilst sterling has enjoyed something of an easy ride against the troubled euro, against the US dollar it has been an altogether different story. Again, market uncertainty best explains the US dollar’s stellar performance in May. It’s fair to say that the market is in a state of panic at the moment, concerned with a ‘Grexit’ and most recently a ‘Spexit.’ Amid such monster question marks, there has been widespread flight to the safest assets such as the US dollar. Sterling may be markedly a safer alternative to the single currency, but its safe-haven status cannot compare with that of the greenback.

The rug has finally been pulled from underneath the EUR/USD pair. The scale of the eurozone’s current problems is now being reflected in the price of the euro; EUR/USD has declined by over 5.0% from $1.3150 to $1.25 in the space of just one month. We do see the EUR/USD pair considerably lower in the coming months, which will inevitably weigh on the GBP/USD pair.

The US dollar is not without its own domestic economic concerns, with recent data confirming that the US economy grew at an annualised pace of 1.9% in Q1, down from the initial estimate of 2.2% and well down from Q4 2011’s 3.0% pace of growth. Progress in the US labour market has also slowed right down, which has once again seen speculation that the US Federal Reserve will introduce QE3 step up a gear. Whilst the US economy is stalling as we enter the summer, it is still firmly in recovery mode. We continue to hold the view that the Fed will want to gather more evidence about the US recovery’s direction before pulling the trigger on more quantitative easing, so we view the current QE3 concerns as over-hyped.

Safe-haven dollar to outperform

Sterling has recently revisited January’s lows below $1.53, having suffered a 6.5% drop against the US dollar in the space of just four and a half weeks. Sterling has finally bounced against the US dollar and is currently trading at $1.55, but we think this will prove temporary. A consolidation period was always likely after such a steep drop, but we should see lower levels tested once this current bout of profit-taking on the dollar’s recent rally has run its course. Lower levels in the $1.51-1.52 area could well be seen in June as the negative eurozone headlines once again take their toll.

Caxton FX one month forecast:

GBP / EUR : 1.26

GBP / USD : 1.5150

EUR / USD : 1.2050

Richard Driver

Analyst – Caxton FX
For the latest forex news and views, follow us on twitter @caxtonfx and sign up to our daily report.

Friday, 1 June 2012

Sterling/Euro June Report


Sterling has continued to rally against the euro in recent weeks, as conditions in the eurozone go from bad to worse. Uncertainty, as ever, is the buzz word. The pro-bailout New Democracy Party has edged ahead in the Greek opinion polls in the past week or so, which has lifted market hopes that the country can receive the additional funding it needs and remain ‘safely’ within the eurozone.  But there is plenty more debate to be had in Greece and few will be truly confident of a positive result ahead of the fresh elections on June 17th.

The chances of a messy ending to the Greek saga remain very high. Even if a pro-austerity, pro-bailout coalition does emerge out of this month’s elections, they will still have to find a way to deliver the major reforms and deficit reduction that the country’s €130bn bailout agreement requires. The EU Commission reminded Greece earlier this week that its bailout payments remain highly contingent but whoever wins this month’s elections, you can expect some desperate efforts to have the bailout terms relaxed to a significant degree.

Greek concerns, though likely to return to the fore as the elections draw closer, have been put on the back burner for the time-being. True to form, another struggling eurozone nation has stepped up to fill the void – Spain, or more specifically, Spain’s banking sector.  Bankia, Spain’s fourth-largest bank, requires €19bn worth of recapitalisation and it is becoming more and more apparent that Spain will need help to shore up its banking sector. The issue is having a significant impact on Spain’s government borrowing costs, with 10-year bond yields climbing dangerously towards the unsustainable 7.0% level. As ever with this debt crisis, market fears build so much they become a self-fulfilling prophecy. In short, Spain is in very serious trouble and may have to seek external help, which is no small issue given it is the eurozone’s fourth-largest economy and will inevitably turn the market’s gaze towards the third-largest – Italy.

The UK economy is looking particularly downbeat at present, having been hit with the confirmation that it is firmly in double-dip recession territory. Unsurprisingly, consumer confidence has taken a sharp downturn. April’s growth data from the services and manufacturing sectors was poor and a gauge of UK retail sales showed the worst figure in almost four years. The last update from the UK labour market was a little more encouraging but we will need to see more than one good month before hoping for sustained improvements.

Amid all of this bad domestic economic news, as well as the grave threats posed by the eurozone debt crisis, it might be assumed that more quantitative easing is bound to be introduced by the Bank of England in order to drag the UK out of recession. Certainly the IMF has made its views known on the issue, encouraging the BoE to act soon to safeguard the UK economy.

However, the noises out of the MPC have not suggested that such a move is imminent, despite the recent sharp decline UK inflation from 3.5% to 3.0%. A key reason for this is that the BoE sees UK inflation in the medium term as equally likely to exceed its 2.0% target as undershoot it.  In addition, Spencer Dale has recently stressed the argument that the recent quantitative easing doses are still feeding through to provide stimulus and that a further round is not appropriate at present. This position is supported by the recent improvement in UK money growth.

With only one MPC policymaker voting in favour of QE at the MPC’s May meeting, in the form of David Miles, there is plenty of dovish recruitment to be done in the coming months if the BoE is to pull the trigger again on further monetary easing. Sterling seems safe in this regard for June at least, though eurozone risks could feasibly escalate sufficiently to prompt BoE action in July or August.  

So, despite the UK economy sitting uncomfortably in a double-dip recession and facing a prolonged period of period of stagnant growth and ultra-low interest rates, sterling looks free to continue taking advantage of an increasingly euro-negative environment. Sterling/Euro climbed a further two cents in May, leaving this pair with gains over 4.0% in the past two months. We envisage further gains for the relative safe-haven pound in June, with the Greek elections and rising Spanish bond yields providing plenty of motivation to exit the euro.

Richard Driver
Analyst – Caxton FX

For the latest forex news and views, follow us on twitter @caxtonfx and sign up to our daily report.

Tuesday, 29 May 2012

The Queen’s Jubilee: Good or Bad for Sterling?

Now there’s no doubt that the people of the UK are welcoming with open arms the extra bank holiday that will be part of the Queen’s Jubilee celebrations. However, if we take the similar example of last year’s Royal Wedding, then we can expect a significant hit to the UK economy.

It is estimated that the Royal Wedding in 2011 weighed on the UK’s gross domestic product (growth) by 0.4%. An extra bank holiday means businesses are closed for longer - economic activity is reduced. Of course, there is likely to be increased spending on the high street and a boost to industries such as leisure and hospitality. This will certainly compensate for some of the impact on UK growth, but not all of it.

The Jubilee looks set to weigh on growth by 0.3 - 0.6% again this year, which is the last thing that the UK’s struggling economy needs right now. Data last week confirmed that not only did the UK economy contract for a second consecutive quarter but by even more than expected (-0.3% q/q). With the Jubilee set to constrain quarterly growth which was only ever likely to be flat at best, we can expect third consecutive quarter of negative growth.

What does this mean for sterling? Well, it won’t necessarily hurt sterling. After all, last week saw the release of some awful UK retail sales growth data, some much weaker domestic inflation data and a downward revision to the Q1 UK GDP figure. Regardless, sterling performed strongly, thanks to the ongoing focus on all things eurozone and the risk averse, sterling-friendly trading conditions this is creating.

Of course the risk remains that more negative growth will convince the MPC that more quantitative easing is necessary, but as yet the majority of the nine policymakers seem happy to let the last round of QE to feed through, particularly with medium-term UK inflation risks well-balanced and present inflation levels still elevated.

One common ‘silver-lining’ lining argument is that while the Jubilee may hurt Q2, the London Olympics are only just around the corner in Q3. Estimates have surfaced that the spending linked to the Olympics will boost UK GDP by 0.5%. We approach these predictions with a great deal of caution though, as do the Bank of England, since the impact and success of mega-events such as the Olympics are highly unpredictable. Sydney 2000 boosted Australia’s economy considerably, while Athens 2004 left the Greek economy crippled.

We maintain a positive view for sterling this year, except against the US dollar, regardless of stagnant/negative growth. Clearly the caveat here is that the picture may change if growth is so poor that the BoE pull the trigger on more QE – a major downside risk for sterling. Looking at the limited impact of the last round of QE on sterling though, there is a good chance sterling will hold up firmly again.

Richard Driver
Analyst – Caxton FX

For the latest forex news and views, follow us on twitter @caxtonfx and sign up to our daily report.

Monday, 28 May 2012

Greek opinion polls provide some hope but confidence still fragile

Greek opinion polls give the market some hope

The euro was given some relief in early Monday trading by the positive news that in Greece, the conservative and pro-austerity party - New Democracy – has edged ahead of the anti-bailout party Syriza in the opinion polls. If New Democracy can hang on to their lead and re-establish a pro-bailout, pro-austerity and pro-euro coalition, then fears of a Greek exit should subside. Judging by the euro’s brief and fairly minor bounce since the weekend though, the market remains understandably cautious.

Concerns over Spain are also growing, as the country’s ten year bond yields climb towards 6.50%, bringing into view the dangerous 7.0% benchmark which forced other peripheral nations, like Portugal and Greece, into requesting bailouts. Spain’s fourth-largest lender Bankia requires a bailout and the Spanish region of Catalonia is also in need of help to refinance its debt. Consequently, the risks of a Spanish sovereign bailout are increasing, which would create a huge amount of stress on the EU’s aid resources, as well as raising major question marks over Italy.

In addition to these mounting Spanish concerns, growth data from the eurozone was all pointing the wrong way last week. Figures from the German, French and eurozone-wide services and manufacturing sectors almost all disappointed, suggesting that the eurozone’s avoidance of economic contraction in Q1 will prove temporary.

With respect to the issue of Eurobonds, Germany doesn’t look like it will budge. What’s more, Austria, the Netherlands and Sweden have joined Germany in expressing their opposition to the idea of common eurozone bonds, so market hopes for a silver bullet have once again been quashed.

US GDP figure should confirm slowdown

This week brings two important growth figures from the US, in the form of the revised GDP estimate for the first quarter of 2012 (due on Thursday). The figure is expected to be revised down from 2.2% to 1.9%, well off Q4 2011’s impressive quarterly reading of 3.0%. Friday brings the monthly update from the US labour market and improvements in this area are expected to be moderate at best.

The US dollar’s safe haven status has very much come to the fore in the past month. Clearly ongoing softness in US figures keeps QE3 on the table as far as the Fed is concerned but we see safe-haven demand helping it appreciate further across the board. In particular, we foresee heavy losses for EUR/USD in the second half of this year, which will inevitably drive GBP/USD lower too.

Sterling is trading up above €1.25 this afternoon, with the positivity surrounding the Greek opinion polls already having dissipated. Sterling weathered some awful data last week, including a downward revision to the UK’s Q1 GDP figure to -0.3% and a steep drop in the domestic inflation rate. However, sterling’s safe-haven status still looks likely to push it even higher against the euro.

In contrast, sterling is always going to be under pressure against the US dollar. It should benefit from a minor short-covering bounce soon, though a return anywhere close to $1.60 looks a stretch now. Risk appetite away from the US dollar is likely to be hard-pushed to return in force ahead of the June 17th Greek elections.

End of week forecast
GBP / EUR 1.26
GBP / USD 1.5750
EUR / USD 1.25
GBP / AUD 1.6050

Richard Driver
Analyst – Caxton FX
For the latest forex news and views, follow us on twitter @caxtonfx and sign up to our daily report.

Thursday, 24 May 2012

UK recession confirmed...and it’s worse than first thought

Data on Wednesday has confirmed that not only did the UK enter a double-dip recession in Q1 of 2012, but it contracted by 0.3%, rather than the -0.2% figure that was initially estimated April. At the time of the initial estimate in April, sterling was spared quite a bit of pain because the market thought it knew better than the Office of National Statistics (which releases the GDP figures). In particular, many questioned the ONS’ assessment of growth in the construction sector. Ironically, a downward revision to construction growth was largely responsible for today's headline.

The MPC was also a little guilty of overestimating UK economic conditions in the first quarter, choosing to focus on some more positive but ultimately misleading PMI surveys from the UK construction, services and manufacturing sectors. Indeed Adam Posen, for his part, has admitted as much.

What seemed like a bright start to the year had definitely fizzled out then and the UK economy is set to struggle for the rest of 2012, possibly contracting by 0.5%, as ongoing UK austerity kicks in and the eurozone crisis weighs on external demand, and internal lending and confidence.

Still though, sterling has weathered Wednesday’s downward GDP revision very well. There is very much a sense that the market is fully aware that UK growth will be stagnant this year, but at least it is getting its public finances in order, and as shown by the UK’s ultra-low borrowing costs, it is clearly removed from the threat of eurozone debt contagion. Sterling’s appeal isn’t based on the imminence of monetary tightening or a positive growth outlook. The pound is basically the poor man’s US dollar, a second tier safe-haven.

In line with a pessimistic outlook for Greece and regardless of the likelihood of further QE from the BoE and the UK’s vulnerability to eurozone developments, we have a positive outlook for sterling against the euro and other risky, commodity currencies like the AUD and ZAR. Clearly, our view is less positive against the US dollar – we see GBP/USD heading down to $1.50 in the second half of this year.

Richard Driver
Analyst – Caxton FX
For the latest forex news and views, follow us on twitter @caxtonfx and sign up to our daily report.

Wednesday, 23 May 2012

MPC minutes reveal no extra doves but QE risks remain prominent

Wednesday’s MPC minutes revealed that David Miles remained the one and only policymaker in favour of an additional round of quantitative easing (£25bn) at the rate-setting committee’s May meeting. We have to admit that we expected one or two other policymakers to give Miles some company in the dovish camp, but we maintain that he won’t be the lone dove for long.

This much has been indicated by Adam Posen, who has been expressing second thoughts with regard to his decision to abandon his calls for QE, pointing to a potential overestimation of UK growth over Q1. We’d be surprised if Posen fall back to his dovish tendencies in June. Though it may take more than Posen to worry holders of sterling, given that a 7-2 split on the QE vote still keeps the dovish very much in the minority.

One major point that could dissuade several policymakers to vote for QE is the fact that they believe UK inflation is equally likely to be above target as below it in the medium term without more monetary stimulus. In addition, current CPI levels, regardless of the recent fall from 3.5% to 3.0%, are high.

Nonetheless, it was stressed that for several members of the committee, the decision was finely balanced and the option remains well and truly on the table. The latest figure from the UK retail sector, combined with the softer start we saw to Q2 in the form of some weak UK PMI surveys, will increase speculation that the UK’s struggling economy is in need of some extra monetary help.

The key factor that could well have the final say on the BoE QE debate is of course the eurozone debt crisis. The situation in Greece has taken a severe turn for the worse since the failure of the ruling coalition to secure sufficient support at its recent general election. A new round of elections is due on June 17th, which could well produce an anti-bailout collation and lead to a Greek euro-exit. Meanwhile, fault lines within the EU leadership have been highlighted this week in Germany’s rejection of French and Italian plans to introduce a common eurozone bond (a Eurobond).

As shown by the euro’s recent slide, confidence in the euro project is waning. We expect the euro-region to return to negative growth this year and the financial shockwaves from a probable Greek exit are expected to be worse than those of Lehman’s. Consequently, we bet we haven’t seen the last of UK quantitative easing in 2012.

Richard Driver
Analyst – Caxton FX

For the latest forex news and views, follow us on twitter @caxtonfx and sign up to our daily report.

Tuesday, 22 May 2012

Euro rebounds a little, but not for long

Sterling’s rally finally comes to a halt

Whilst sterling remains strong against the commodity currencies, it has suffered somewhat against the euro and the US dollar in recent sessions. The Bank of England’s Quarterly Inflation Report proved the catalyst for a significant bout of profit-taking on the pound’s rally. The Report saw the BoE downgrade its longer-term inflation and growth forecasts, sounding particularly dovish whilst doing so. Concerns over whether the BoE will introduce further quantitative easing have increased as a result, which has weighed on the pound significantly.

The week ahead brings with it plenty of risks for sterling. Wednesday’s minutes will once again bring BoE monetary policy back into focus – all eyes will be on how the MPC voted on QE in its May meeting. David Miles is likely to have stuck to his pro-QE stance and one or two others may well have been convinced by his arguments, which would be sterling-negative. Comments from the once reliably dovish Adam Posen have also added to QE bets. Posen publically questioned the wisdom of his decision not to vote for QE at the MPC’s May meeting, suggesting he can be counted on to do so again in coming months. Inflation data this morning has seen the headline rate come down pretty sharply from 3.5% to 3.0%, once again bolstering arguments in favour of monetary easing.

Also on Wednesday we have the release of April’s growth data from the UK’s retail sector. Having seen the wettest April since records began, the figure is expected to show a fairly sizeable contraction, particularly after the excellent growth seen in March. Thursday brings the revised UK GDP figure for the first quarter of this year. No amendment from the initial estimate of -0.2%, so the figure is unlikely to be a source of great support for the pound.

On the face of it then, it looks to be a tough week ahead for the pound. In addition to these domestic announcements, risk appetite away from safer currencies such as sterling looks to be staging a minor recovery. With the potentially disastrous effects of a Greek euro-exit now sunk in, if not fully priced in, we may well have seen the worst of investor panic. That is of course until the Greek elections come into view in the build up to the June 17th Greek elections. Sterling’s safe-haven demand looks set to come back to the fore ahead of this huge risk event.

G8 pledge support for Greece to remain within euro

The leaders of the world’s eight largest industrialised nations backed Greece to remain within the single currency over the weekend. With Germany sticking to its demands for austerity though (and who can really blame them?), it’s tough to see how the situation can lead to anything but a Greek default and euro-exit.

The profit-taking on sterling’s rally has taken the GBP/EUR rate down to its current level of €1.2350. It is difficult to see sterling losing too much more ground to the euro given the uncertainty that is lurking in June but with sterling facing several risky announcements this week, we may see today’s sideways trading theme dominate direction this week.

Against the dollar, sterling continues to feel the heat and is now trading down at $1.58. We expect to see the USD maintain its current demand, though its recent rate of appreciation is clearly unsustainable. EUR/USD has staged a minor recovery, having touched a 4-month low around $1.2650. We are going to need to see further climb from the current level of $1.2770 towards $1.30 if we are to revise calls for much lower levels in coming weeks.

End of week forecast
GBP / EUR 1.24
GBP / USD 1.57
EUR / USD 1.27
GBP / AUD 1.60

Richard Driver
Caxton FX