Caxton FX Weekly Round-Up: Italy shocks markets

Italian elections ease the heat off the pound for now
Italy has really dropped a bomb on the financial markets with the results of its parliamentary elections this week. No party secured an overall majority.  Centre –left pre-election favourite Bersani secured a majority in the lower house but things are a lot messier in the Senate, where Berlusconi secured enough seats for a blocking minority.

Market tensions are bound to rise; Monti – the man who has delivered significant economic reforms and calmed market fears since he took over at the end of 2011 – received only 10% of the votes, while anti-austerity leader  Berlusconi took almost 30% of the vote.

All eyes are now on the coalition-building process and how Italian bond yields respond. Benchmark 10-year Italian bond yields have risen by almost 9.0% today. The key concern in the financial markets is that Italy can form a government which sticks to its reform programme. It remains to be seen whether or not Bersani can conjure a coalition but market sentiment towards the Italian political situation is likely to remain shaky for weeks to come.

Moody’s finally downgrades the UK’s credit rating
Friday night brought the long-awaited loss of the UK’s AAA credit rating. The move was so well sign-posted that it can’t have caught any market players as a genuine surprise, though it still gave them an excuse to punish the pound further. Fortunately for GBP, the Italian election results have understandably stolen focus.

Looking ahead, the UK PMIs are coming up in the next week; Friday’s manufacturing gauge is expected to pick up slightly on Friday, while no change is expected within the second estimate of UK GDP in Q4 2012.

MPC policymaker Paul Tucker revealed today that no one in the committee thinks that quantitative easing has reached the end of the road, confirming that more can be expected later this year. Sentiment towards the pound remains very weak and it will likely take further panic headlines out of the eurozone for GBP to build on this week’s gains.

Bernanke remains dovish but dollar still rises
Bernanke’s speech today has confirmed that he still lies on the distinctly dovish side of the debate within the US Federal Reserve. The Fed Chairman stressed the benefits of quantitative easing and the costs of high unemployment. This suggests more evidence of momentum in the US recovery will be necessary before Bernanke begins to taper off QE3.

The safe-haven US dollar, along with the yen and Swiss franc, has been a key beneficiary of the tensions coming out of Italy. Firmer US data has also been supportive of the greenback, with consumer confidence and home sales figures coming in well above expectations.

End of week forecast

GBP / EUR	1.1550
GBP / USD	1.5025
EUR / USD	1.3000
GBP / AUD	1.4775

Sterling is trading at €1.16 today and while there is a significant chance of a further bounce up to the €1.18 level, on balance we expect this pair’s downward bias will take hold once again. In terms of GBP/USD, we are predictably comfortable with targeting lower levels.  A move closer to $1.50 is likely before the next mini bounce. Meanwhile we are expecting lower levels in the EUR/USD pair, which currently trades at $1.3050.

Richard Driver
Currency Analyst
Caxton FX

BoE edges towards QE, Fed edges away, while the eurozone remains firmly in recession

We have to hold our hands up and admit that we were caught well and truly offside with respect yesterday’s MPC minutes. We did not even fully expect David Miles to continue voting for QE but not only did he stand firm, he recruited to additional doves to his cause in the shape of Paul Fisher and (more significantly) Sir Mervyn King. With the merits of an interest rate cut also carefully discussed, it was no surprise to see sterling take a beating as a result. We have to now change our position on the BoE’s monetary policy outlook and expect an additional top-up of QE around May time. Not good news for sterling, which continues to suffer from weak growth and the high probability of a UK debt downgrade.

By contrast, the minutes from the US Federal Reserve’s recent meeting gave a real boost to the US dollar last night. They revealed that Bernanke & Co are assessing when and how to scale back their QE3 operations, which was a major driver of dollar-weakness in the last few months of 2012. There have been hints that substantial improvements to the US unemployment rate would be needed before QE3 was wound down but the minutes revealed there was some support for doing so before such improvements are seen. It goes without saying that there remains majority support for maintaining QE3 as it is until greater progress is made with the US recovery and no change to this looks particularly imminent. However, the discussion and the divergence of views within the Fed could lead to a tapering off of QE3 later on in the year. This is why the dollar has rallied.

From the eurozone, we have had yet more weak growth data. A German economic sentiment survey was excellent earlier on in the week but this morning’s PMI figures pointed to a slowdown in the powerhouse economy this month. The German manufacturing sector remained in growth territory by only the smallest margin. Meanwhile, French figures pointed to a sharp dip further into contraction, against expectations of stabilisation. The same is true for the eurozone as a whole, which is set to contract again this quarter.  This is being reflected in a weaker euro today, though GBP remains very vulnerable. 

Richard Driver
Currency Analyst
Caxton FX

Caxton FX Weekly Round-up and Outlook

Weak UK data puts further downward pressure on the pound

The prospects for a strong return to growth for the UK retail sector in January seemed very reasonable based on anecdotal evidence but Friday’s -0.6% stopped us dead in our tracks. When you combine this with the Bank of England’s Quarterly Inflation Report, which highlighted an outlook of weak growth and persistently high inflation over the next few years, it is little wonder that sterling has failed to bounce back in the past few sessions.

The MPC minutes are released on Wednesday and despite poor economic figures, we believe it is more likely that the lone QE voter David Miles dropped his vote than actually recruiting other members to his cause. The high inflation outlook really doesn’t seem consistent with additional QE, particularly while the Funding for Lending Scheme is providing the UK economy with support. Whilst Sir Mervyn King did state last week that the MPC stands ready to do more QE if necessary, we still believe his doubts over how much more this can achieve will dominate the voting in the coming months.

What hasn’t been helpful to the pound today have been Martin Weale’s weekend comments supporting a weaker pound to aid exports and address the UK’s current account deficit. Some might have interpreted this as a rare foray into the dangerous field of verbal intervention but we doubt it was much more than an example of wishful thinking.

Euro gets away with awful eurozone GDP figures

GDP data from throughout the eurozone, which significantly included Germany, was very disappointing last week. The euro is trading at a three-week low against the US dollar as a result of this confirmation that the eurozone recession is worse than many had feared, but levels above $1.33 are still pretty firm. Meanwhile, the euro continues to bully the pound down below €1.16.  

News out of the eurozone may have been bad last week but hopes are rather higher for this week’s eurozone data. Further improvements are expected within this week’s key German economic sentiment and business climate gauges. Meanwhile, Thursday’s eurozone PMI figures are expected to point to stabilization, even if the region does remain in recession territory.

US dollar enjoying plenty of demand amid firmer data

Recent headlines out of the US have been upbeat; weekly unemployment claims data improved sharply, while manufacturing and consumer sentiment figures also impressed. This provided a timely contrast with awful data out of the UK and the eurozone and may well have reminded many players why the USD should, in our view, be preferred to the EUR and GBP (in spite of QE3). The week ahead brings the minutes from the last Fed meeting (Wednesday), which could well reveal some discussion as to when QE3 can start to be scaled back. The bar remains pretty high in respect to this but discussion alone should be USD-positive.

End of week forecast

GBP / EUR	1.1500
GBP / USD	1.5400
EUR / USD	1.3400
GBP / AUD	1.5100

Sterling is trading below €1.16 this afternoon and we suspect the rate will head lower from here, with levels close to €1.15 representing a realistic target. It continues to prove tricky to call a bottom on GBP/USD’s slide but we think the pair will take a close look at $1.54 before a bounce is in sight.

Richard Driver
Currency Analyst
Caxton FX

Eurozone growth data comes back to haunt the euro

Data this morning has confirmed that the eurozone remains very much in recession. We knew that this was the case, but we didn’t know quite conditions were quite this bad. In the final three months of 2012, the French economy contracted by 0.3%, Germany’s by 0.6% and Italy’s by 0.9%, with all three GDP figures coming in worse than market expectations. The euro weakened on all of these data releases. Perhaps surprisingly, given that the market had the above figures already out in the open, the euro also weakened as a result of the overall eurozone GDP figure, which revealed a 0.6% contraction. Meanwhile, Portugal also posted a 1.8% contraction, while the Netherlands shrank by 0.2%. Spain we know contracted by 0.7%. Suddenly the UK’s Q4 GDP figure of -0.3% doesn't seem quite so disastrous. 

The market has been content to ignore weak eurozone data in recent months and as a result the euro has had an easy ride. Super Mario (Draghi) said he would do whatever it takes to keep the euro afloat, Greece managed to kick the can further down the road, and bond yields have been brought under control. All is well? All is not well - these eurozone figures are a reality check and really bring home what the market has seemingly been willing to sweep under the carpet. 

Perhaps the market is not ignoring it and perhaps they are looking beyond at a recovery in 2014, basking in the relief that the debt crisis no longer threatens the very existence of the euro. Either way, if data like today's continues to filter through in 2013 without significant improvement, then the ECB will be forced to act by cutting interest rates and you can be sure that the market will sit up and take notice when that happens. Germany has posted some encouraging figures so far in 2013 but it is anything but plain sailing for the euro from here.

The strong eurozone exchange rate over the past few months will surely have contributed to these awful eurozone GDP figures. The ECB remains reluctant to intervene to weaken the euro but they will have limits to what sorts of levels they are willing to tolerate. This is a key factor behind EUR/USD’s stalling ahead of $1.40. Next up, the Italian elections - expect the nerves to continue jangling over the next week or so. 

Richard Driver

Currency Analyst

Caxton FX

February Currency Outlook: GBP, USD, EUR

February 2013 Corporate Report:  Sterling friendless

January was another rough month for the pound, against almost every major currency, and the coming weeks do not look likely to be particularly fertile for a recovery. Sterling has been among the poorest performing currencies in the market, with a wide range of concerns over the UK economy weighing heavily. There are risks of a triple-dip UK recession, which in turn raise the probability of further quantitative easing from the Bank of England and a loss of the UK’s AAA credit rating. Until UK growth shows some signs of a recovery, the pound is likely to remain under pressure.

The euro’s remarkable rally continued in January, helped by further market calm in the eurozone and subsequent improvements to global market sentiment. ECB President Draghi gave the euro plenty of support by quashing speculation that his central bank would opt to cut interest rates (watch out tomorrow for further rhetoric). This optimistic approach has actually been bolstered by significant improvements to German economic data, even if growth in Italy, Spain and France remains very weak indeed. It only takes one look at bond yields in Italy and Spain to realise that nerves towards the debt crisis are at a low ebb and that confidence is pretty stable. That said, the past week has seen tensions rise ahead of Italy’s election this month.

Other than against the euro, the US dollar is also in pretty good shape. However, the recent weak US GDP figure for Q4 2012 hasn’t done the greenback any favours and will play into the hands of Ben Bernanke and the other dovish leaning policymakers within the US Federal Reserve. Positive sentiment towards the euro looks likely to limit the dollar’s gains in the coming weeks, but we still expect the USD to have a strong 2013.

GBP/EUR

Triple-dip fears dog the pound

Sterling is hugely out of favour at present; depreciation was so drastic in January that sterling’s trade-weighted index dropped by the most since February 2010. Economic weakness, speculation of more UK monetary easing and a more general loss of faith in the GBP as a safe-haven are all issues which have weighed heavily. The warnings as to a UK debt downgrade have been understandable and whilst predicting the timing of a downgrade is tricky, it would surprise us if the move was delayed beyond June.

Does sterling really deserve the battering it has received? Well, it certainly deserved some punishment; negative growth and a lack of progress on the UK’s debt situation are always issues likely to make themselves felt on the exchange rates.

There remain some brighter spots within the UK economy; the Funding for Lending Scheme appears to be bearing some fruit - bank lending is on an uptrend. The UK labour market continues to defy the wider domestic downturn. However, these rare good news stories have been of little use to sterling, with investors questioning how positive these factors can really be if they are not resulting in any genuine economic growth.

Unfortunately it’s quite clear that it will not be a particularly robust start to 2013, thanks to January’s snowy weather. The truth is that last summer’s Olympics concealed very weak underlying growth, which will become even more apparent over the rest of Q1. Sterling has at least been granted the relief that the UK services sector returned to growth in January but the risks of a triple-dip recession are still finely balanced.

Despite weak growth, we do not expect the Bank of England to opt for another dose of quantitative easing at its February meeting on Thursday, with most members satisfied with the Funding for Lending Scheme as an alternative to QE. David Miles is likely to remain the only voter in favour of QE in the February 7^th meeting; we expect the MPC under Sir Mervyn King to continue opting against further easing.

What will be more interesting on February 7^th will be Mark Carney’s appearance in front of the Treasury Select Committee. The market will be watching very closely for clues as to how Carney, who will take over from King as BoE Governor on July 1^st, will approach monetary policy. Unlike King’s comparatively hawkish doubts over the efficacy of more QE, Carney has been vocal on the utility of further easing and has pointed to other “unconventional instruments” which suggests he will strike a more dovish tone on Thursday. This is unlikely to be good news for the pound.

Germany perks up to help the euro

Once again, it’s been fairly quiet on the eurozone front, which has been a major factor behind the ongoing gains being made by the euro across the board. The weak investor sentiment towards the eurozone that characterised so much of 2012 is being unwound, as the risks of a eurozone break-up recede.

German data has been particularly encouraging in recent weeks with forward-looking sentiment and confidence surveys hitting multi-month highs. Still, the PMIs out of the eurozone as a whole continue to point to further economic contraction, which should lead to euro-weakness later on in the year. However, at present the market appears content to overlook awful growth and celebrate the signs that the worst of the debt crisis is behind us. This is really why GBP/EUR’s decline has been so aggressive.

There is evidence of burgeoning political tensions in the eurozone. Italy’s elections are scheduled for February 24-25 and considerable uncertainty lingers with respect to the outcome, particularly with the latest polls suggesting that Berlusconi is closing the gap. In addition, there is scope for Berlusconi’s PdL party to block the governing coalition’s laws in the upper house. Elsewhere, there are calls for Spanish PM Rajoy to resign after having been embroiled in a corruption scandal. This could potentially derail Spain’s reform programme and damage the stability we have seen in peripheral bond yields.

On the monetary policy front, ECB President Draghi has been very helpful to the euro, sending strong signals that he will not elect to cut interest rates once again, regardless of weak eurozone growth and record-high unemployment. Also propping up the euro has been Draghi’s refusal to express concern at the euro’s impressive rally to 15-month highs against the pound and US dollar. Euro bears will be watching this Thursday’s press conference very Draghi closely for signs that he is uncomfortable with the euro at current levels. We suspect they may be disappointed.

Sterling has depreciated by around 6.0% from where it started the year (marginally above €1.23). Amid the ongoing anti-sterling sentiment that is still simmering away, we don’t expect that this pair’s trough of €1.1470 will be as low as it goes. If Draghi sounds in confident mood on Thursday, we’d expect the downside to be tested once again in the coming weeks, with significant risks of a move down to €1.1364 (88p). However, we do expect this pair to bottom out soon and remain confident of a sterling recovery thereafter.

GBP/USD

Dollar flexes its muscles despite stalling US growth

The news out of the US economy has been typically mixed over recent weeks and there was no real change in stance from Ben Bernanke and the US Federal Reserve as a result. The fourth quarter US GDP figure for 2012 actually confirmed a surprise 0.1% contraction, rather than the modest 1.1% growth that was expected. In addition, the US unemployment rate jumped back up to 7.9%, which considering Bernanke’s obsession with bringing the jobless rate right down before ending QE3, was not good news for the US dollar.

The market has been correct not to panic at the US economy’s weakness at the end of last year, much of which can be put down to the effects of Hurricane Sandy. The Fed was clear that it was a case of growth pausing as opposed to it representing the beginning of another dip back into recession.

The GBP/USD pair’s sharp decline in the year to date has finally started to reflect the contrasting conditions and outlooks for the UK and US economies. Whilst the US has suffered some temporary weakness, 

underlying growth is still in decent shape and this will continue to be the case in 2013. The UK, by contrast, did not grow in 2012 and will struggle to eke out much growth in 2013.

An interesting theme over recent weeks has been the US dollar’s strong performance against currencies like the GBP, despite its extreme weakness against the EUR (EUR/USD climbed to a 15-month high only last week). We are already seeing concerns over the political situation in Spain and Italy spark doubts over how much higher EUR/USD can go. If we see the downward correction in EUR/USD that we continue to expect, then we expect GBP/USD to suffer as a result. Sterling is struggling with weak domestic news as it is, without major euro-dollar flows adding further pressure. This may well be delayed until later on in the year but it would be no real surprise if it came sooner. 

We may see GBP make another attempt above the $1.57 level in February but we expect that would represent an attractive level at which to sell. This should signal another move lower and potentially take this pair to fresh 6-month lows below the recently hit $1.5650 level.

GBP/EUR: €1.14

GBP/USD: $1.55

EUR/USD: $1.3650